Question:
Why was the Navajo language was considered by the Japanese to be an “unbreakable” code (in ww2)? ?
Sarah
2008-12-19 17:38:47 UTC
Used in world war 2 as code.
Eighteen answers:
Robeo
2008-12-19 17:48:07 UTC
Excellent question !

It is cultural. Yes, the answers listed already added most of the obstacles for the Japanese. No written language. All american Indians had different languages.

One factor is -- The Navajo used animals to describe machines. Example, the giant tortoise is etc. With all of the ways they spoke in an unknown language -- was impossible. They said toroise not turtle etc.
anonymous
2008-12-20 01:45:33 UTC
The Code Talker's primary job was to talk and transmit information on tactics, troop movements, orders and other vital battlefield information via telegraphs and radios in their native dialect.



A major advantage of the code talker system was its speed. The method of using Morse code often took hours where as, the Navajos handled a message in minutes. It has been said that if was not for the Navajo Code Talker's, the Marines would have never taken Iwo Jima.



The Navajo's unwritten language was understood by fewer than 30 non-Navajo's at the time of WWII. The size and complexity of the language made the code extremely difficult to comprehend, much less decipher. It was not until 1968 that the code became declassified by the US Government.
Ron D
2008-12-21 04:59:45 UTC
Actually the code itself was pretty simple, using familiar Navajo words like wooliche' meaning red ants to mean, for example, a batalion of soldiers. Even Navajos, captured by the Japanese, who heard the codetalker tranmissions didn't have a clue what they were saying. The literal translation was the red ants were meeting over at the chapter house, or something like that.



Unless you knew the code, even native speakers didn't know what was going on which made the code double-layered. By the way, I hear there were also Comanche codetalkers as well. Same concept.
Chokonen888
2008-12-20 06:35:21 UTC
I speak Japanese and know a decent amount of Na Dene (The language the Navajo, Apache, and even Native Alaskans speak) but I make no claims of being a linguist. I never really looked into it (and now, maybe I will) but there are alot of words that are the same between Japanese and Na Dene...Japanese, Mongolians, and Many Native American Tribes that speak Na Dene share DNA roots...and considering the similarity of many words, I'd guess the languages share the same roots as well.



With that being said, let me give you some examples....



Dog in Japanese and Na Dene is INU. Sky in both languages is SORA. There and here is Achi kochi in Japanese and Aji Koji in Na Dene.



So...I doubt the code was "unbreakable" and I laugh to hear that Na Dene is unrelated to any other languages as it's more widespread than you think.
xo379
2008-12-20 01:42:36 UTC
Johnston believed Navajo answered the military requirement for an undecipherable code because Navajo is an unwritten language of extreme complexity. Its syntax and tonal qualities, not to mention dialects, make it unintelligible to anyone without extensive exposure and training. It has no alphabet or symbols, and is spoken only on the Navajo lands of the American Southwest. One estimate indicates that less than 30 non-Navajos, none of them Japanese, could understand the language at the outbreak of World War II.



http://www.history.navy.mil/faqs/faq61-2.htm
ANDREW L
2008-12-20 01:52:35 UTC
Read the later part of this wiki article.



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_talker



BTW this was not an unbreakable code but rather a code that could not be broken in a timely fashion when used tactically (e.g. have the infantry go around to the right). If for instance it had been used for strategic messages (e.g. send the fleet to the Solomons) the Japanese probably could of broken the code using academic resources. (I now see the Wiki article addresses this issue)
anonymous
2008-12-20 01:42:09 UTC
because you had to be a navajo to understand the language...it wasn't a code that could be broken with equations and patterns, so the only way to break it is to have a navajo translator
old lady
2008-12-20 03:40:56 UTC
Because it was spoken by so few people, and almost no one outside of the Navajo Nation understood it. So the Japanese weren't able to crack it.
Big D
2008-12-20 01:42:23 UTC
Because only a few people speak Navajo.
RebeccaJV
2008-12-20 02:16:39 UTC
It was not linguisticly related to any common language. French, Italian and Spanish are all latin languages so you can decipher commonalities among them. There was nothing to compare the navajo language to.
jan51601
2008-12-20 02:10:22 UTC
Before World War II, every code that the United States had created for warfare had been broken. Known as experts at code deciphering, the Japanese were never able to decipher the Navajo's secret code.

The success of the code was due, in a large part, to the complexity of the Navajo language. At the outbreak of World War II, there were only thirty non-Navajos who could speak the language, and not all of them could speak it fluently. Philip Johnston, had grown up on the Navajo Reservation, and could speak Navajo very well. He was a veteran of World War I, and had heard about a battle in that war, in which several Choctaw Indians were talking to each other by radio in their native language. It completely fooled the Germans, who were listening. The tide of the battle turned around, and the Americans won. With his knowledge of the Navajo people and their language, Mr. Johnston thought that the Navajos could easily devise a way of talking that no one would be able to understand.

With the somewhat skeptical approval by the U.S. Marines of Mr. Johnston's idea, recruitment for Code Talkers began in the spring of 1942. Two recruiters from the U.S. Marine Corps went to the Navajo Reservation and met with Chee Dodge, Chairman of the Tribal Council. He liked the idea and sent out word by shortwave radio to the Reservation. There was an immediate, excited response. The candidates had to be fluent in both English and Navajo. Many of them were just school boys and lied about their age, just to have the opportunity to go and fight for their country and protect it from the Japanese. Twenty-nine Navajos were inducted into the Marines.

When the first Navajos started to develop a code, they never realized the task that lay ahead of them. First they had to learn military and field terms in English. Then they had to create a Navajo equivalent for each of these terms. In order to maintain secrecy, no written version of any code was ever allowed in the battle zones. They had to commit every word to memory. While creating the code, the Code Talkers used four basic rules to make memorization easier.

1.) The code words had to have some kind of logical

connection to the term to which they referred

2.) Code words had to be unusually descriptive

3.) Code words had to be short

4.) They had to avoid words that could be confused

with similar words

For example, different aircraft were given the name of different birds that acted similar to the planes. For instance a dive bomber was much like a sparrow hawk to the Navajos, so it was called a gini; their word for sparrow hawk.

In order to be able to include other words in their code, besides the assigned terms, the Code Talkers added an alphabet code. They took the English letter and thought of something that started with the letter, and then used the Navajo word for that object. They then used a group of Navajo words to spell out an English word. In order to say "Navy" in Navajo Code they could say for instance, "tsah (needle) wol-la-chee (ant) ah-keh-di- glini (victor) tsah-ah-dzoh (yucca)." When they received a message, it either had terms they knew, or alphabet words which they could translate using the first letters of English words. In this way, the Code Talkers could encode anything!

The success of the code was due to the fact that Navajo families lived by themselves, on remote Reservations, and not together as a tribe for many of their earlier years. This kept their language from being known to almost anyone other than themselves. When the former chief of intelligence for the Japanese forces, General Seizo Arisue, found out many years after the war, that the code used by the the Americans was an American Indian Code, he replied, "Thank you. That was a puzzle I thought would never have been solved."



The language itself is a tonal language, meaning the vowels rise and fall when pronounced, changing meaning with pitch. There are four separate tones of voice used: low, high, rising, and falling. Two separate words with different meanings may therefore have the same pronunciation but with different tones. Some Navajo words are also nasalized, meaning that the sound comes through the nose instead of the mouth. The Navajo language is very difficult for non-Navajos to understand because of the precise way in which one object relates to another. Their view of life, which is that everything they do and that happens to them is related to the world around them, is very apparent in the way they speak. For example, a Navajo would not say, "I am hungry," but instead would say, "Hunger is hurting me." It has been said that in Navajo, words paint a picture in your mind.



At the bottom of http://library.thinkquest.org/J002073F/thinkquest/The_code.htm (has a recorded message of code talking done by Wilfred E. Billey saying,

"Request artillery fire on hill 105" . No wonder the Japanese couldn't br
Alexa M.
2008-12-20 01:43:42 UTC
im guessing your doing your homework and got stuck right...it was unbreakable because the navajo made up their own language and if you weren't a navajo you didn't know their language ...its not something you learn ...like if you and your friend made up a language and talked in front of me i would have no clue...you feel me
Dave S
2008-12-20 01:41:12 UTC
how many people do you know who speak Navajo,
anonymous
2008-12-20 01:42:11 UTC
becasue they had never heard it before and it was only spoken by the native americans so the japanies had no idea what it was
Andrew
2008-12-20 01:41:50 UTC
The language is oral(spoken) only.

No written version of it exists except for pronounciation keys.
anonymous
2008-12-20 01:43:13 UTC
Nazi included, people just didn't know that lang.
anonymous
2008-12-20 01:42:23 UTC
Because it was smoke signals and the Japanese had no clue how to read them.Only those who use smoke signals can understand them.
kevin m
2008-12-20 01:41:40 UTC
they were too busy doing math to figure it out.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...