Question:
How did people in the 1600s know how to build large stone buildings such as the cathedrals to last?
CO the Old Dog
2013-05-30 14:58:27 UTC
when peoples in the Middle East, Europe and the West can not seem to make buildings that will last now?
Ten answers:
2013-05-30 22:14:58 UTC
People have constructed buildings and other structures since prehistory, including bridges, amphitheatres, dams, electricity pylons, roads and canals. Building materials in present use have a long history and some of the structures built thousands of years ago can still be regarded as remarkable. The history of construction overlaps that of structural engineering. To understand why things were constructed the way they were, we also need to rely on archaeology to record the form of the parts that survive and the tools used, and other branches of history and architecture to investigate how the builders lived and recorded their accomplishments.



Chronological development



The history of construction is a complex subject encompassing the history of building materials, the history of engineering, the history of building techniques, economic and social history of builders and workmen, the history of construction machinery and temporary works, etc. Each of these has a complex literature devoted to it.

Neolithic construction

Neolithic buildings in Skara Brae, Skara Brae is listed as a UNESCO world heritage site



The first bridges made by humans were probably wooden logs placed across a stream. The first buildings were simple huts, tents and shelters meant to suit the basic needs of protection from the elements, built by their inhabitants (see self-sufficiency). The very simplest shelters, tents, leave no traces. Because of this, what little we can say about very early construction is mostly conjecture and based on what we know about the way nomadic hunter-gatherers and herdsmen in remote areas build shelters today. The absence of metal tools placed limitations on the materials that could be worked, but it was still possible to build quite elaborate stone structures with ingenuity using dry-stone-walling techniques (see the stone structures at Skara Brae). The first mud bricks, formed with the hands rather than wooden moulds, belong to the late Neolithic period and were found in Jericho. One of the largest structures of this period was the Neolithic long house. In all cases of timber structures in these very early cultures, only the very lowest parts of the walls and post holes are unearthed in archaeological excavations, making reconstruction of the upper parts of these buildings purely conjectural. The most remarkable Neolithic structure in Western Europe is the iconic monument known as Stonehenge, regarded by some archaeologists as displaying methods of timber construction (such as at woodhenge) translated into stone.[1] The now ruinous remains are of post and lintel construction and include massive sandstone lintels which were located on supporting uprights by means of mortise and tenon joints; the lintels themselves being end-jointed by the use of toggle joints (tongue and groove). There is also evidence of prefabrication of the stonework; the symmetrical
Variable 46
2013-05-31 21:35:36 UTC
Several people have mentioned "trial and error," and that was probably a part of the process. But less "error" than people might think. It was the Renaissance and a new science was emerging that allowed for the construction of these fabulous buildings. You also have to consider that the most magnificent buildings of the day, i.e., the churches, were constructed under the auspices of the rich and powerful, who could afford the best and brightest builders. AND also that for even the most commonplace of stone buildings, some of the best rock was easily available. Also remember that the biggest buildings took 3 to 5 generations of workers to build (over 100 years in some cases).



What I find amazing is how, in the hand-to-mouth existence that most common people lived in the Middle Ages, that they went along with the orders of an opulent church that demanded such sacrifice. Such was the fear of fire and brimstone instilled by the "church," I suppose...a force still capable of intimidating much of the populace today.
2016-03-11 00:44:59 UTC
The early church worshipped in whatever building or place that was suitable and available: a disused temple, a cave, a hillside, river bank, or even somebody's home. Neither Jesus nor the Apostles encourage Christians to build temples / church buildings. In John 4:21-24, Jesus declares that a time is coming where worship will not be tied to any particular location or building. For the first few hundred years of the Christian faith, special church buildings were very rare. It was not until Constantine and his succeeding Roman Emperors started the Roman Catholic Church and made it the official State religion of the Roman Empire that they began to build "Christian" temples. The grand basilicas and cathedrals were based on the design of Pagan Temples/ Roman Public buildings and were often built on the site of former pagan places of worship. In some cases they just took over a pagan temple or Government building and "christianised" it.
Jay R
2013-05-30 15:01:20 UTC
Trial and error. Not all stone buildings stayed up. Also, there was a tradition of building in stone that went back to ancient times so that knowledge was brought forward through the ages.
Raatz
2013-05-31 08:21:10 UTC
Trial and error. They didn't know they were going to last...the ones that didn't fell down. Buildings and bridges fell down a lot back then.
wHaT eVeR
2013-05-30 15:47:14 UTC
It was a Trade that was taught down from one family member to the next.
?
2013-05-30 17:17:33 UTC
I often was amazed at the pyramids built BC, that was an art, and in those days allot of hard work, and unfortunately, most of it was slave labor.
2013-05-30 19:46:46 UTC
Takes ingenuity,creativity,intelligence,for thought,strength and agility. Minds that go the distance.
Dan
2013-05-30 15:15:46 UTC
That's because modern people like to recycle.
2013-05-30 20:02:42 UTC
They were smart back then without digital technology


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...