Question:
Why did the germans fail to defeat the Soviets in 1941?
2008-03-10 05:26:58 UTC
Why did the germans fail to defeat the Soviets in 1941?
Eleven answers:
Toroguy
2008-03-10 05:59:04 UTC
There are several reasons that accounted for the loss.



- Most importantly the strong russian winters. My grandfather said that suddenly at night the air was full of loud explosive noises. When they got up and checked, it was trees exploding from water freezing within.



- Too long support lines. When the advance came to a halt due to building resistance, there was no way to support the immense support lines for fuel, ammunition and spare parts.



- No usable roads. When the ice melted in spring the country turned into a giant swamp. Everything clogged up, sank and got stuck.



- Bad planning. Headquarters expected a successful quick Blitz attack. Troops were ill equipped for the environmental conditions once that tactic failed.



- Micro Management of technological accessoires. Where the soviets had - if at all - standard equipment, the germans had a dozen different tanks, a dozen different other vehicles and numerous types of guns and ammunition. All this amassed to so many different spare parts needed, that it couldn't be maintained and covered by the support routes. Lots of equipment needed to be left behind and destroyed.



- The russians didn't care how many of them died. I learned from a soviet veteran that only the first row had rifles. They were commanded into german machine gun fire at gun sight and when they fell, the troops following them (unarmed) picked up their guns and continued on.



One of the most gruesome wars ever fought.
risque juliet
2008-03-10 06:03:45 UTC
German war planners grossly underestimated the mobilisation potential of the Red Army (it was about twice as large as they had expected).



A failure in logistical planning by the Germans was another. The start of the war, in the dry summer, was the most favorable for the Germans, as they took the Soviets by surprise and destroyed a large part of the Soviet army in the first weeks. When favorable weather conditions gave way to the harsh conditions of the fall and winter and the Soviet Army recovered, the German offensive began to falter. The German army could not be sufficiently supplied for prolonged combat; indeed there was simply not enough fuel available to let the whole of the army reach its intended objectives. This was well understood by the German supply units even before the operation, but their warnings were disregarded.



The German forces were not prepared to deal with the poor road network of the USSR. In autumn, the terrain slowed the Germans' progress. Few roads were paved. The ground in the USSR was very loose sand in the summer, sticky muck in the autumn, and heavy snow during the winter. The German tanks had narrow treads with little traction and poor flotation in mud. In contrast, the new generation of Soviet tanks such as the T-34 and KV had wider tracks and were far more mobile in these conditions.



German troops were mostly unprepared for the harsh weather changes in the autumn and winter of 1941. Equipment had been prepared for such winter conditions, but the ability to move it up front over the severely overstrained transport network did not exist. Consequently, the troops were not equipped with adequate cold-weather gear, and some soldiers had to pack newspapers into their jackets to stay warm while temperatures dropped to record levels of at least -30 °C.



A common myth is that the combination of deep mud, followed by snow, stopped all military movement in the harsh Russian winter. In fact, military operations were slowed by these factors, but much more so on the German side than on the Soviet side.
sdvwallingford
2008-03-10 07:13:52 UTC
These are all the standard answers, but they are incorrect. The German army was defeated before the cold began. (I like Agility Man's answer, though, it came in while I was answering. Good Job!)



There were a number of very bad decisions along the way to Moscow that Hitler made which combined to stymy Operation Barbarossa. First, Soviet resistance in the south (ie-Ukraine) was much more formidable than was expected or than was found in the center and the north. At a key moment, when Marshall Budyonny was building a million strong army group around Kiev, Hitler decided to halt the operation towards Moscow and divert all of Army Group Center's armored forces south across country, then after the battle they had to travel back across country north for the general advance to begin again. This was specifically because Hitler had decided to begin the overall invasion with the absolute minimum number of forces necessary for victory, so the German army had absolutely NO strategic reserves.



Meanwhile, to the north, against Stalin's orders, the commanders at Leningrad offered to surrender the city if the Germans promised to treat it as open and undefended. Hitler ordered that since his intention was to demolish the birthplace of Bolshevism anyways, the city was to be bombed and shelled into rubble and the entire civilian population killed before the German army would occupy it. What should have been a simple surrender ceremony turned into a three year long siege that was a constant drain on the German war effort.



Then, after the strike towards Moscow began again, Soviet resistance again collapsed and Hitler felt that the war with Russia was over. Feeling that, with a completely war-based economy (ie-no consumer goods to spend increased wages paid to a society with almost no unemployment) such a limited production with no monetary outlet would result in crippling hyper-inflation, Hitler ordered the demilitarization of over 40 divisions and the return of their manpower to the economy BEFORE the Soviets actually asked for terms.



In the initial planning for Barbarossa, it was well known that the concept of the Blitzkrieg (lightning war) required the immediate delivery of overwhelming force AND supplies to the key point in the battlefied no matter where that may be. It was also well known that the transportation infrastructure in the Soviet Union simply could not sustain this sort of operation. At no point was this problem dealt with, and in fact was the reason why the diversion of forces from Moscow to Kiev and back had such a cataclysmic effect on the invasion timetable. It would also play a dramatic role in the decisions of what supplies to deliver to the German army at key moments in the overall campaign.



Finally, when the winter actually did arrive (as everyone else has suggested), Hitler decided that Moscow was now the center of all his military world and the city must be taken at all costs. With the belief that if the city fell in the first campaign season then the entire Soviet war effort would collapse, Hitler ordered that the distribution of winter clothing should stop and that only food, fuel and ammunition be delivered to the front line soldiers (the idea that the Germans were surprised by the winter is a misnomer or worse; not only does it regularly get cold in Germany, but by this time the German army had already fought an extensive campaign above the Arctic Circle; this was another calculated risk on Hitler's part).



All of these decisions (with the exception of Leningrad) are not in themselves totally bad, and at least in some measure make military sense. However, the fact that they all occurred in the same campaign, and that Hitler had decided to go into the invasion while leaving absolutely no margin for error or, as Clausewitz called it, friction (unanticipated problems), doomed the invasion to failure almost from the very first day. For the invasion to work, the Soviets would have to obey all of Hitler's preconsieved racial notions as to their genetic stupidity AND the laws of time would have to stop (Stalin helped with the first, but Hitler had driven Einstein into emigrating to the USA so he was out of luck!)
2008-03-10 07:58:51 UTC
The Germans had long planned to invade the Soviet Union, and were prepared to begin in late March/early April of 1941, but there was a snag. Hitler wanted the Balkan peninsula (Greece, Bulgaria, Yugoslavia, etc) incorporated into the Reich in order to cement the Reich's underbelly, but the Yugos and Greeks refused, so instead of invading the USSR in April of 1941, Hitler invaded the Balkan Peninsula.



This delayed the invasion of the Soviet Union (USSR) until the end of June. I'm sure that there were Generals and politicians who cautioned Hitler that an invasion so late in the year would lead to a winter war in the USSR, but like Bush in 2003, Hitler banished anyone who wouldn't tell him what he wanted to hear!



The invasion of the USSR didn't start until June 24, 1941, a day that will live...At first, blitzkrieg (literally 'lightning war') went as it did in Poland and France (and Holland, and Denmark, and Norway, and ...) but because of the late start the campaign dragged on until...Mother Russia's Winter struck back.



Because there were no cautioning voices around der Fuhrer (see above) there was no one to say that the campaign might last to winter, so no winter uniforms were issued. Hitler had planned to conquer the Soviets in a few months! With no winter uniforms the soldiers began to freeze, their equipment froze, and the rest...is History.
Agility Man
2008-03-10 06:12:14 UTC
Is your question: why did the Germans fail to beat the Soviets (ie: Operation Barbarossa failed?) or is it why did their initial efforts in 1941 fail so that their offensive stretched into 1942, 43?



Several factors:

1. Hitler underestimated the impact of the sheer size of Russia. People have this image of the Wehrmacht as being nothing but tanks and mechanized gear. Far from it--at the time of Operation Barbarossa, the majority of the German Army was on foot. Without any opposition at all, you would be hard-pressed to walk from Poland to Moscow in one summer. As German forced pushed eastward, supply logistics became even more problematic and shortages began to constrain the German advance.



2. Weather. There was a late spring in 1941 in Russia which resulted in both a later jump-off to the invasion plus muddier roads (and thus a slower advance despite the lack of credible and organized Russian defenses initially). And then this led to the Germans being stuck in Russia in winter. By the time an early snowfall hit, the Germans were stopped by the weather and could effectively go no further.



3. Muddled strategy and Hitler's interference. Hitler diverted the main thrust from Moscow to focus on the Ukraine in the South. By the time the Southern flank had been secured and the Ukraine captured, the onset of winter had nearly begun and the capture of Moscow was close but not likely. Also related to this mindful of Napoleon's disasterous retreat from Moscow, in the winter of "41 Hitler decreed that no German troops would retreat. Unprepared for winter and often stuck in poorly defensible positions this resulted in them being buffeted by Soviet counterattacks that winter.



4. In that first year of the war, Stalin traded lives for time. He threw bodies of troops into combat with nearly suicidal decisions. This was especially true for the fights around Moscow, Brest, Kiev and Sevastopol, where some troops went into battle without weapons or ammunition.



All of these are reasons why the '41 offensive failed. Here is why beyond '41 the Germans were bled white on the Eastern Front:

--Russian military capability. After the first year of the war, the incompetent Russian Army (Stalin had purged the officer corps, equipment was undermaintained and over-rated) was tested in the fire of combat and better leaders and equipment (T-34 tank) emerged. It went from a mostly incompetent and numerically superior force to a tactically strong, often capable and in some cases better equipped force that outnumbered the Germans.

--Space. The Nazis were caught on the defensive and Russia was too big to defend against the Russian counter-offensives. A smarter German strategy would have been to concede space and withdraw hundreds of miles to more defensible lines. Instead, the Germans persisted with offensive manuevers (pushing as far east as Stalingrad) while still being forced to defend, became ignorantly fixated on capturing some terrain (Stalingrad, Lenningrad/St. Petersburg) at all costs rather than developing a coherent and sound strategy given the spatial and weather realities of fighting in Russia.

--strategic stupidity. The Germans aligned with the Japanese, Pearl Harbor happened, they ended up having to fight a war against the USA which now began shipping supplies to the Russians in earnest, the number of fronts the Germans were engaged on would soon multiply rapidly.

--underestimated the ability of the Russians to mobilize new troops. The Russians formed new armies faster than the Germans could destroy or capture them.



In the end, it was probably a fool's mission to defeat Russia. It is arguable that despite the weather and a few other elements, there was simply no way that the German Army as constituted in 1941 could defeat the Russians. The Wehrmacht covered 300 miles on 1 week to start the war but ran to the end of their supply lines. It isn't even clear that the fall of Moscow would have led to the defeat of Russia.
2008-03-10 05:35:11 UTC
As far as I know, they didn't expect the extreme coldness and weren't prepared. It was an extreme cold winter in 1941 and the nazi government were so fanatic, they didn't take that into account. Apart from that, they fought too many countries at that time. It was the year when Stauffenberg and his officers attempted to kill hitler, and I believe, the nazi regime's military failure and their lack of care for their own soldiers, apart from the horrible atrocities against people they didn't consider humans, was one reason of the decision to dispose of him. If they had succeeded, they wouldn't only have freed the world of one horrible monster, but would have called the soldiers back home as well.
susieboo
2008-03-10 06:57:28 UTC
Nature
pao d historian
2008-03-10 05:35:48 UTC
there are many factors. one factor that greatly influenced the movement is because of the cold weather. Germany tried to capture Moscow but this was halted because of climate conditions. another is that Germans are not well planned on their advancements in Russia. Russia was able to make numerous counter attacks because of the lack of tactics of Germans. a hard frozen soil during those times and Russians are more adapted to it compared to Germans. there are more other reasons and it will be better if you search it for your own.



Have a nice day!
george.gauthierdc
2008-03-10 07:08:53 UTC
Others have given some really fine answers already, so I will limit myself to suggesting an article in the Wikipedia:



Eastern Front (World War II)
remowlms
2008-03-10 05:34:39 UTC
The Germans were fighting on multiple fronts and were not prepared for winter battles. It also didn't help that they had a little nut job in charge.
iamsuranovi
2008-03-10 05:33:08 UTC
The Soviet winter snuck up and bit them in the wazzoo...


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...