Question:
Does anyone believe that I know what happened to Amelia Earhart?
2008-08-20 20:39:07 UTC
When my dad was a kid he lived in Le roy NY, there was a crazy lady named Jenny Vitel (I don't really know how to spell it). She always wore and aviator cap. She is dead now, but she was the same age as Amelia Earhart. She lived by herself and didn't have contact with any relatives. Le Roy was the birthplace of Jello and the jello museum is there. Amelia Earhart was friends with the man who owned the factory and she gave him a chair from the cockpit of her plane.

Does anyone else think they are the same person?
Thirteen answers:
2008-08-20 23:16:25 UTC
Amelia Earhart was mostly a publicity stunt. Her first notoriety was for being the "first woman to fly across the Atlantic", but she actually went as a passenger. The two men hired to fly her across spent the two weeks they had to wait in Newfoundland for clear enough weather to give it a try drinking fiercely. Im sure they expected to die, because it was still extremely dangerous and more people had died trying it than had made it across. The flight took about 18 hours and photos taken after the landing in Ireland show a smiling Amelia and two very haggard men.



G. P. Putnam, the publisher, had dumped his wife to marry Amelia, scandalizing his family and his adult children, who were roughly Amelia's age. It was G. P who financed Amelia's around-the-world effort. Because this time she intended to fly the airplane herself, no one could be found who would go along with her as navigator/radio operator except the alcoholic Fred Noonan. They actually made it more than halfway, but probably the most difficult leg was their undoing. There was a long flight over open water, which provided Noonan no landmarks for confirmation of his navigation. There was a Coast Guard cutter positioned to provide a radio beacon, and the ship did have brief contact, but the radio direction finding technology of the day could only narrow things down to reciprocal bearings. You had two possible locations with respect to the RDF, and they were 180 degrees opposite. The confusion from this and Noonan's poor navigation skills meant they could not find the flyspeck Howland Island in the vast expanse of ocean.



There have been numerous speculations and tales regarding the ultimate fate of Noonan and Earhart. One was that they crashlanded in a lagoon in the Marshall Islands, which the Japanese were busily fortifying, in violation of their League of Nations Mandate to the islands. This was purportedly witnessed by a native who related the tale when she was very old. The Japanese either assumed she was a spy, or decided she had to die to keep their fortifying the islands a secret.



Another which was interesting was aired several years ago. It was based on a flat piece of metal, which may have been the lid of a map box of the sort that Noonan might have been expected to have, and on the heel of a shoe, of the type of flat that Amelia is seen wearing in photos as she readied herself for departure. These items were found on an uninhabited island within a radius that they might have reached. Some wealthy mystery hunters had pledged an all out further investigation, but nothing more has been made public of which I am aware.



This was a huge news event in 1937 and the area is so remote that there is virtually no way she could have slipped out of the area and returned to live out her life in obscurity in a New York hamlet. Why would she not return to G. P. and the easy life and further exploits his millions would have made possible?
2008-08-20 20:53:47 UTC
Not a chance, Amelia Earhart crashed in the Pacific ocean when her plane ran out of fuel. She had been sending radio transmissions and circling looking for land all the while she was saying that she was running low on fuel. Her last transmission abruptly ended when she crashed and died. Unfortunately for her she was not skilled at using the radio so she was able to send transmissions but not receive them which is why her transmissions were heard but nobody was able to communicate with her.



It's very clear what happened to her but some people think that because the plane has not been found that she may have survived but those people don't take into account just how big an ocean is when you're searching for a small plane that is at the bottom.
2008-08-21 17:22:24 UTC
The most definitive explanation is offered in a best selling book "Amelia Earhart Survived" by Rollin C. Reineck. Here's in an article from that book:



http://home.pacbell.net/vten/earhart.html



Good luck!
96 ZORRO LT1
2008-08-20 21:59:12 UTC
i might be crazy but i think she crashed on an island somewhere and with the war going on i belive the Japanese found the wreck and destroyed whatever was left so the americans would never really know what happened i don't think they captured her i think she was already dead they just destroyed any evidence and now its been so long no one will ever know just a thought
2008-08-20 20:44:06 UTC
if she was crazy she could have had a personality disorder and thought she was amelia earhart
2008-08-20 20:42:57 UTC
That's interesting and you should research it more but I think she died at sea or something still. DNA testing if your serious but does anybody have Amelia's DNA?
Rockin' Rosette
2008-08-20 20:43:22 UTC
No....A.E. took off from Hawaii in questionable weather and was never heard from again....I doubt it that she flew all the way to New York.
raging_stalin
2008-08-20 20:42:31 UTC
Only a DNA test can answer your question.
?
2008-08-20 20:43:17 UTC
lol No, and I also don't believe the story. Nice try, though.
:)
2008-08-20 20:43:40 UTC
I knew a black guy...he lived in the united states somewhere....i think it was will smith!!!! omg omg omg omg
2008-08-20 20:46:54 UTC
You need to just shutup, and put out....
Spud
2008-08-21 09:00:39 UTC
Yeah, but no, but yeah, but no but...........maybe. I'm not sure.
2008-08-20 20:42:53 UTC
why do you think we care? I know I don't


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...