Question:
How do historical buildings and monuments in Singapore contribute to our national identity?
1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
How do historical buildings and monuments in Singapore contribute to our national identity?
181 answers:
Ebrahim
2006-07-23 01:51:30 UTC
as without them we would not realise how the past looked liked and how people use to live.it also tells us that what and who build the building like if we saw a British building we would know that ,that building is there because the British ruled Singapore for a certain period
dolphines70
2006-07-22 23:29:26 UTC
It help us to remember our past achievement and also by keeping historical buildings it help us to show and tell the new generation about the history rather then just read from the book which they unable to link.



It always bring back a lot of memory for a lot of people who involve and stay at the place.



With historical buildings and monuments, it help to show how the country have gone through and how hard the people have live in and how they build the country.
BOTAK2006
2006-07-22 23:07:52 UTC
Yes,Historical buildings and monuments in Singapore contribute to our national identity.





Historical buildings and monuments must be preserve. As this will allow Singaporean to know the history of Singapore. The architectural and artistic of the historical building. Take example, why tourist like to go china and visit the historical cave, example Du haung cave?



Tourist like to go there because they are curious about the development of Buddhism and the artistic artifact of the caves.



Same like if a tourist were to come Singapore and visit the historical buildings and monuments in Singapore. Take for example, national library .National library is the 1st library in Singapore. Tourist will be very disappointed when they find out the National library have been demolish.



Lastly, if one day the Changi air port are to become a historical buildings and monuments in Singapore. And worst still is government is to redevelop it to a residential area. Will Singaporean agreed on this? As for me i will disagreed, as Changi airport give us an identity of being the world class airport in the word.Furthermore, Changi air port is an important icon.
jason k
2006-07-22 06:59:46 UTC
It can show how Singapore developed and how it became famous because of its historical links.
Specky B
2006-07-21 23:26:02 UTC
I am born in Singapore in 1969. My memories of my "home" is always affixed at a few places where I can associate with during my childhood days. Like the old Satay Club, where my family used to have dinner together at No. 1 stall (you can still see the pix hanging somewhere in Changi Airport....is it still there???). There was a pavillion where me and my sisters used to play after dinner...is it still there???



Now, with the new durian structure, new glutton square, new bridge, etc...Singapore is now getting strange to me..as I am not able to associate the "places" to my "home". It is now just another place to pass by.



To answer your question; historical monuments can contribute to our national identity by constantly reminding us who we are, why are we here, where do we live, what makes us remember this place and how much we love this place, etc



Identity is associating our life with the place
Ramsam51
2006-07-21 10:57:23 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments are structures built/erected to capture memorable events of the past. Events that are of national interest then that help to shape the future of Singapore now. By looking at these structures, one is reminded of what we were in the past or what we have achieved then and these historical buildings and monuments of the past is something that we associated ourselves with today and as everyone Singaporean share those things, collectively, we then have a national identity albeit a teeny weeny one. At least, that is a common ground that all Singaporeans share. At least, until such time when we can call ourselves truly Singaporeans instead of by race, language and religion.
Great O
2006-07-21 02:10:51 UTC
The historical buildings and monuments represent what makes Singapore unique compared to other countries and show our historical influences. After seeing many cathedrals, castles, cobbled streets in Europe, there sometimes is a sense of sameness that one makes us wonder whether it's worth visiting the next castle or cathedral, even if its in a different European country. Singapore's buildings and moments provide an interesting story of the influences we have had, whether it be Indian, Chinese, Pernakan, European etc. I believe we should continue to design and build buildings and monuments that can last centuries and have that unique Singapore flavour. Who knows, 50 years from now, we'll look back at the Esplanade and say, that's what Singapore is and what makes Singapore a contrast from Malaysia and Indonesia's architecture.
nur y
2006-07-20 23:08:42 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments in Spore play an essential role in contribution of our national identity. Being an avid history student during my school days , i find it hard to visualise how spore look like in her days before independence.Visual couldn't feed my curiosity. I strongly believed that no matter how advance n how developed spore may turn herself into , we are in dire need for places that symbolised how we started as a young nation, our influences, and the character of our forefathers.



Seeing is believing and it is a totally different perspective and vibes u get out of it.



Monuments do contribute a great deal to our national identity. Have you ever been to City Hall on Saturdays? where you will find punks and skinheads loitering and hanging around? As we all know these minorities have their own origins and their own teachings. Yet these youngsters cannot adhere to those things being in a developed society.



Yes they waste themselves but why do they choose to hang around these historical sites? I believe that even though they have their own thinking and concept, without us realising it, these people are true to their concept and at the same time adapting themselves to Singapore in her present time. whether u are a punk , a skinhead, a skateboarder. whoever you are, u are still a contented Singaporean and it makes u proud to show to tourist the and the orchids. Made in Singapore.
aew2004
2006-07-20 22:32:32 UTC
These buildings and monuments, have been around since before we were born. In this modern age, it would be very rare to find buildings that are old and seeped in history. It would tell of how Singapore began and the present day will attest to what we have achieved.

So the old building, testify to where we come from, what we have been through, what we have achieved.

It is a marker for our progress. and at the same time to remind us never to forget where we come from or our heritage, which is responsible for who we are today.
sweetie
2006-07-21 19:25:56 UTC
Familiar places and buildings give us a sense of continuity with the past, and help to develop an emotional attachment to our land. In re-making Singapore, we need to retain a stock of buildings that create a special sense of identity and hold our individual and collective memories. Like precious family heirlooms that are passed from generation to generation, they can create an enduring bond between generations. Such buildings lend soul to our city and make it different from all the others. Conservation must be integral to urban planning in Singapore.



Architectural works of the post-war era for conservation. Despite their simple forms, these buildings are important for their social and historical significance. They are part of the memories of the post-war generation. They document the evolution of building styles in Singapore, and are fine examples of the work of our pioneering local architects. Most importantly, they capture the mood and aspirations of a young Singapore nation. Through their conservation, we hope to safeguard symbols of Singapore’s modernizing and industrializing era.
2006-07-22 20:33:18 UTC
Well i think that historical buildings does contributes to our national identity, good times... bad times almost everything. Although i sometimes feel that some buildings are better off gone, rather than being there hindering Singapore's further development, but yes we should still try our best to preserve them as they are the result of our forefathers hard work and should be kept as a memory.



We talk about perseverance of our historical monuments all the time, but why is that some of them are destroyed while some are left the way they are? Most of the time its because the space occupied by kept monuments or buildings are not needed for development. For example the battle box, we wont be doing anything with some space underground, unless we need a wine cellar or something. Might as well just leave it there to remember how the British lost to the Japanese(not that it was any good), and earn some cash along the way.



Historical buildings and monuments provide us with memory of the past, how we got here, what we have gone through and what me must do to continue. They provide us with bits and pieces of important information that we may forget but should also be demolished if they hinder our development. I think we are always stuck in a dilemma to either to keep or destroy. I guess that's what the government is for, not that i like all of their decision but yes, we humans some how need a leader before we can do anything right.
richielim29
2006-07-20 21:11:26 UTC
Basically, we all know that Singapore is a small country. We have no natural resources, no world class themeparks like DisneyLand for others to remember by etc etc, history wise not really long compared to the Americans and Europeans, but that is something which we can remember by and it is this very history which have united SIngaporeans and brought us where we are today.



No doubt Singapore is rapidly developing itself so as keep up or even surpass the international standard, but it is the very existence of these historical buildings and monuments and the stories from our grandparents which have bridged the gap to our past, to the hardwork of our forefathers.



Take for example the clarke quay and boat quay stretch, this was the very place where it all happened when Raffles landed in Singapore and that was the day Singapore was borned. Though it has been revamped to restaurants, pubs and shops, but the original structure and buildings remained.



The younger generation can still have the opportunity to have a glimpse at the past and whenever we all see the statue of Sir Stamford Raffles standing proudly overlooking the Singapore River, as well as the bronze statues of coolies along the River, we will all realise that the Singapore today did not just become the way it is today without the hardwork of all our forefather.



Lastly, i would like to applaud the URA for their efforts in conservating the built heritage as an integral part of urban planning and development in Singapore. The restoration of our historical buildings and monuments not only provide variety to our street and landscapes, it also checks the scale of our urban fabric, creating visual contrast and excitement within and around Singapore while protecting the important reminders and representations of our past as i have mentioned earlier. It also adds to the distinctive character and identity of Singapore, giving it a sense of history and memory of the place.
peanutz
2006-07-21 08:20:00 UTC
Given our nation's short history, we do nat have much that we can truly call our heritage. Thus it becomes more important urgent and important that we preserve the few historical buildings and monuments we have left, especially since independence the Government has not build anything that can be considered monumental or historical.



In the earky days, we still had various world war 2 memorials along the Esplanade. Sadly, some of them had given way to redevelopment and I think we lost a part of our ties to the past. I remember the fountain and the memorial to those fallen in fighting for the country. Guess these were too strongly colonial.in nature.



Probably the main reason is that Singapore is too land-scarce, hence the need to sacrifice heritage for the sake of development. The importance of development to generate growth for the country I guess takes precedence over all else. Though I feel a compromise should have been achieved. Parks can be created still in the city to break the monotony of the city skyline. and yet preserves those monuments. Though it is too late to cry over spilt milk, hopefully this can be done for whatever is left behind.



The Tourism Board had designated certain places as heritage sites, but, they do not have the stature of a heritage site. They are mostly just a point, a spot. One minute and you are through. really I wonder how tourists feel about these as tourist spots.. They have to spend time at the spot to read the history. But where is the atmosphere? Where are the linkages to the place, people or event?



I had been to Adelaide and I marvel at the way there are old and new modern buildings standing side by side. The city wants to progress, but still preserves the old buildings that lend character to the city. Same as in Melbourne. You get nice big parks with proper monuments located within. Same as when I go to Thailand. There are various parks located in the city of Bangkok and there are monuments dedicated to the past and present rulers.



We do need to preserve whatever we have left. One landmark is the former General Post Office, the Fullerton Building. Once a Government building, now it is a hotel. The landmark instead of being turned into a heritage site for visitors now welcome paying guests. Renovations and additions to make it livable mean that its former majestic character is now diminished. I guess there are more examples to citred that had been turned into commercial prospects.



Keeping and preserving national identity has to be the Government effort. They can gazzette and earmark and dictate how the surroundings can be developed to blend with the preservation site. It cannot be contracted to private businesses or organisations to do this. This needs national attention if we are to preserve whatever is left. Too many old buildings are being turned into commercial buildings in private hands now.



We do not have a long history to develop a national identity. So the few we have become of great importance in this aspect.
newtonwhe
2006-07-21 06:14:35 UTC
A picture represents a thousand words. When tourists come to Singapore, they need not rely on pages & pages of notes to understand what the historic building represent. They take a look then briefly read what it represents and done deal, they know everything. Singapore is so small therefore the small amount of historic buildings & monuments. This is the important part to the answer to this question. When tourists go back home, they will start spreading around what they saw in Singapore. They will start saying & saying and by the time they are done, they may have in fact said out everything they saw in Singapore. So, that is how these facts form our national identity. Small country = few historic places = Our national identity. That's the answer to this question.
-KJ-
2006-07-23 03:56:28 UTC
I think old buildings should be conserved simply because the heritage of Singapore must be preserved, lest the future generations forget totally about what about these old buildings and monuments.



Old buildings help us to remember our History. An example is that some buildings have intricate carvings and they probably showed us how meticulous the people were last time. Items and artifects also give us valuable insights to the nations identity because they give us clues as to who occupied the space before etc.



Historical sites say that even though we're a young nation, we have come thus far. These artifects / buildings date back to more than 42 years ago. This can show us how much Singapore has progressed throughout the years.
foody
2016-10-30 12:39:08 UTC
Singapore Historical Sites
Daniel R
2006-07-23 19:53:44 UTC
Historical buildings are inheritances from one generation to another. They tell us of the culture and what was it like in history of our multi-racial country.



I believe it would be a good thing to conserve various historical buildings to learn more about how the aesthetics were like back then and the design aspects they had to create the structures in those days.



Every building has its own story.



I wonder, how many people do keep things from their childhood? Like toys, old magazines, gifts, stamp collections, etc... Well, I do keep some as they still bring some fresh memories about my past and the stories that had been made up from that unique item that were collected back then, and also how I was like when I was younger.



Same for every historical building. All of them that were conserved holds a huge story in Singapore's growth from a small state to a prosporous nation.



Not all old buildings should be kept though. Some may have deteriorated to an unsightly state and that it is best left to be converted to a new place of commerce or residence.



Like personal collections, I do not keep every old item that has been damaged badly through weather conditions. These items remained now as a memory.



However, no doubt these old buildings do add a charm to Singapore's unique history. It will be good to re-visit some familiar sites and reminisce the good times people had there.
albertina_ou
2006-07-21 01:44:03 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments are an important part of the landscape of Singapore. They tell us the stories behind our country, and they tell us how we have progressed. As the saying goes, "a picture paints a thousand words", so I believe that the buildings and landscape of Singapore can teach us about the history of Singapore better than words can.



Just the other day, I passed by a man selling pictures of Singapore in the past. I found the Singapore in those pictures charming and rich culturally. I was particularly taken with the picture of Jubilee Theater, and those of the Samsui women, and of course those of Chinatown. I think it is sad a lot of these buildings are no more around. Nonetheless, from these pictures, I had some idea of how people lived in Singapore in the past, and of how much our country has evolved. Similarly, historical buildings and monuments in Singapore can teach us or give us some idea of our history, and our national identity.
genm79
2006-07-20 19:37:53 UTC
With the preservation of historic buildings and Monuments, it shows us how it was like during the period of time of construction esp. for Buildings.



Buildings which reflects the colonial government which ruled the country. Districts where different ethnic groups lived. These show us the living lifestyle of the people who use to live or work in them.



Monuments are for us to remember a person or an event which had huge impact in our national history. A statue of Sir Standford Raffles, the founder of the modern Singapore, the Coastal Defence sites that are littered around the Island. Fort Siloso of Sentosa. These are all reminders of People and Events.



National Identity is something that is irrelevent if you do not know your own National History. Therefore historic buildings and mornuments need to be Presvered, Be it the Actual Building or even in other forms of Media.
pika_ang
2006-07-21 08:41:09 UTC
Historical buildings / monuments are built for certain purposes. The historical buildings help to identity Singapore's history. With the buildings still standing in this modern city, it helps to recall memories of the older generation and helps the younger generations to be able to see and feel the history of Singapore.



For the monuments, they are built to remember some historical events/people. When people see the monuments, for those who already know the history, it will remind them of Singapore's history and the events that contribute to the Singapore today. For those who do not know the history, when they see the monuments, they will get to know the reason for building and thus understand the events that had taken place.
Larina
2006-07-21 22:47:43 UTC
As Singapore is still consider a new nation with less then a century of independance, our historical buildings and monuments are countable. The historical buildings and monuments in Singapore are just like the thumbprints of the country and without them, how can our own people recongnize our own country? We need to care for them now to allow our futures to enjoy, and our presents to feel belong. All tourists that had been to Singapore would say that our country is so clean and shoppings are so good but we want more then just that! We want to be able to recommend them places to go for site-seeing during their next visit to our seaport and being proud of calling her our home. Only with the memories of the past can help us better shape our futures... and the buildings and monuments are the reminders of what we had been thru and what we should preserve and improve on our journey towards the future as a team.
Queenie Tay
2006-07-21 21:51:54 UTC
Each & every historical building & monument in Singapore tells us & reminds us a story of the past that contribute to our national identity. E.g. the statue of Stamford Raffles, the Merlion, the Supreme Court, the old shophouses, to the grand Fullerton Hotel (which used to be a Post Office). It will stir interest & fond memories in the general public, including foreigners, about the history of Singapore & how Singapore has become along the way.



All historical buildings & monuments should be conserved to keep our national identity for our generation & the generations to come. They are part of Singapore that is not to be taken away. Nothing beats historical books & records than the historical building or monument itself.
2006-07-21 10:52:38 UTC
A national identity is is like the soul of a country. It is more so the essense or a 'spirit' of a country.



In Singapore, our national identity is very much determined and represented in our love for food and shopping, in our 'kisasuism', our desire to always be world best, our national day parades, our special language, Singlish, our special Merlion and 'Durian' Esplanade.



But how and where would historical buildings and monuments come in? Are they are representation of our past? If they are, then how much and in what way do they contribute to our identity as a NATION?



The creation of a 'soul' does not solely lie in the past of a country. It also lies very much on the present dynamics and the country's percieved future and what the leaders of the country have already set the sights on them becoming.



Historical buildings and monuments are like the hardware in the building of a national identity.. the software; ie, the people, the culture, their lifestyle are also crucial in the creation of a national identity.



So while these historical buildings and monuments are important, they will only serve to create our national identity if they are made complete with our present, our future and our people.



Historical buildings and monuments may be a representation of who we were and what we did. However, without proper education to understand and appreciate fully all that our forefathers did, without the proper passing down of their hardworking spirit, historical buildings and monuments would at most be good tourist attractions with good stories to tell.



Talk about the merlion and most Singaporeans will be able to make an association with it since it represents Singapore. Ask them about how the merlion came about and what it stands for and most people will draw a blank.



Personally, I feel that for most younger generation Singaporeans, historical buildings and monuments are just surface representation of the national identity since most people do not appreciate these buildings and monuments for what they are or represent anyway as many of our historical buildings and monuments have already been refurbished and now house swanky hotels and restaurants.



Coincidentally, what these refurbished historical buildings do represent could be not so much the history of our nation. Rather, it is our Singaporean attitude of constantly wanting to 'upgrade' ourselves and our constant struggle to keep our Asian roots.



So how do historical buildings and monuments in Singapore contribute to our national identity?



They do so by just being there. By changing with the times to reflect our thinking, by becoming a piece of history we can hold on to and by being a reminder to all in the nation that THIS IS SINGAPORE, THIS IS WHAT THE COUNTRY HAS FOUGHT HARD TO BECOME, AND THIS IS WHAT WE WILL BECOME.
2006-07-21 00:38:12 UTC
The historical buildings and momuments in Singapore should be conserved as it preserves a sense of history; reminding us where we came from and how life was like back then. It is a rather unique and in-your-face way of letting people know how life was like for the pioneers. They enable us to connect with history in a way no textbook or university lecture can ever offer.



And it's not only the physical aspect of the buliding that we have to consider. We can learn alot about culture and practices from the people that lived and/or worked in these buildings.



Ironically, these old buildings are also a mark of progress when placed nearby newly built skyscrapers. Take the shophouses along the streets of chinatown surrounded by the tall buildings of the CBD. This contrast does not only contribute to architectural diversity but also reminds us of the progress that we have made so far.



It is also very interesting to note that most historical monuments and bulidings are actually places of wordship. The sultan mosques, the sri mariamman temple, the thian hock keng and the armenian chruch all represent different groups of people in singapore. This makes it much easier for a single singaporean who is curious to find out about his roots and specific culture and role in singapore both in the past and present.



With a firm grasp of where you came from, then only will you be able to understand and totally assimilate and appreciate your role as a singaporean.
clks99
2006-07-20 21:26:57 UTC
We must have our historical building and monuments maintained and restored if necessary.



This is so we and our children, and future generations know about what Singapore was in the bygone days, when life was a little bit simpler, and how we have become a global city state.



If we removed all the these, we will be no different from any other cities, with all the tall buildings that has no character and feelings.



Our historical buildings and monuments will stand the test of time, and remind us of our past struggles through the times, to build a nation that we are all proud to call home.
JasonLee
2006-07-20 20:22:22 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments are a tribute to the past whether it is a good or bad memory. It contributes to Singapore heritage, showing the stages of development and what influenced the development/people.



I see national identity as an attachment of the present, how other countries see us now.



High tech IT infrastructure with a pool of well educated professional, run by an established 'authoritarian' (I did say how others perceive us :) government. Singapore is a hub for almost all diversed businesses. Recent developments such as the Esplanade shows how committed we are. Future developments in the financial and entertainment area shows our determination in striving to be the best.



National identity are also contributed by brand names such as Singapore Airlines which exudes quality first-class service. Not to mention Changi Airport which has won awards and praise around the world.



Singaporeans going overseas have an impact on national identity too. Not to long ago, they were a bunch of arrogant, bad-mannered, misbehaving Asians.



Our participation into competitions is another factor. We can all remember South Korea in the FIFA World Cup - how that did wonders to raise the level of interest and awareness for their country.



What we do, how we do it, how we contribute to the world is our National Identity.
mjpgildea
2006-07-23 21:18:43 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments in Singapore contribute to national identity by being an existing testament to the development of the nation; they make people aware of how Singapore gradually evolved from its many influences, shown by architecture, into the multi cultural and multi racial society that one enjoys today. Without for example the Peranakan shop houses or the bold colonial constructions, there would be a gap, or "a missing link" in peoples' understanding of where they came from, and perhaps where they are going to, i.e., where their futures will be. National identity needs many components but without the foundation and active demonstration of history, through building and monument, it will never be thoroughly achieved because there would be no commonality of interest and a feeling of belonging between people, and very little to relate to. National identity cannot be based on a modern shopping centre, for example, but it can be forged based on buildings and monuments which illustrate visibly the path to nationhood through their very existence.
jadesring
2006-07-23 09:25:57 UTC
The Preservation of Monuments Board (PMB), a statutory board within the Government of Singapore under the Ministry of Information, Communications and the Arts (MICA), has so far gazetted 58 buildings and structures in Singapore as the National Monuments of Singapore. These buildings are deemed to be of special historic, traditional, archaeological, architectural or artistic value.
Dani
2006-07-22 18:29:47 UTC
Every face tells a story and so does every building. The Central Fire Station tower was supposed to be the tallest in the earliest days of Singapore. It gives the fire fighter a "bird's eye" view of Singapore. Whenever there is a fire, the fire fighter will be at the tower to see where fire the broke out. This is one of things that Singaporeans might not know. Bugis Village, used to once famous for some night scene.. Newton Circle supposed to have the best seafood for tourists and the locals, it has been renovated so many times till I lost the warm touch of the place. Look at Chinatown, it has lost its flavour and even locals are not attracted to it.. I wonder, how can Singapore be "uniquely Singapore" when we have nothing historical the tourists to see? In the new future, our young will lose their national identity because there will be nothing of historical to show them about how Singapore was last time.
Teezi
2006-07-22 11:55:00 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments in Singapore can contribute to our national identity mainly because we can use that to attract tourists,we can show the world what Singapore went through in order to be able to create one national identity regardless of race,language or religion, also to educate our children on how our ancestors lived through those tough times.

It not only can let them(tourists and younger ones alike) see how lifes were at that time,it will also let them have a sense of belonging to the place,nothing beats having experience the real thing,we can show them tons and tons of pictures and photographs but having seen the bulidings and exactly being in the buildings itself can do wonders to a person's point of view.

Tourists and younger ones aside,having these historical buildings and monuments around will also create this wonderful contrast of new and old.With all those skyscrapers ever so willing to reach the sky and beyond.Here are those short and sturdy historical buildings standing proudly beside them,just like our parents who laboured throughout their lives with just one hope , to see their children reach for the sky and beyond.

Therefore with the historical buildings and monuments around can really serve us a reminder not to forget the past.

The past that brings Singapore to where she is today.

With that, we can show the world that Singapore is a place where the new will prosper and the old will never be forgotten.

A national identity that present and future Singaporeans can be proud of.
teenie_popper
2006-07-22 08:22:11 UTC
Buildings and monuments reflects a certain era, the thoughts of those who designed and built it, those who lived in it and the historical events that took place there. These historical landmarks and icons are part of Singapore's heritage and culture. You won't think about Paris if you mentioned the Merlion. You won't think about Tokyo if you mentioned Changi Aiport, which is a leading international airport known globally with great service. You won't find a duplicate of these Singapore icons elswhere. These buildings and monuments contributes not only to the past, the present but also to the future of Singapore. It connects people islandwide and gives Singapore a unique identity to be proud of.
mel mel
2006-07-21 06:47:09 UTC
Singapore is a multi cultural and racial society, thus giving our nation a unique style and identity. The historical buildings and monuments from different ethnic groups are part of what reflect our uniqueness to the world, just like the seven wonders of the world (of which most are man-made buildings and monuments).



Demolishing some old buildings (as little as possible) to make space for the new, state-of-the-art complexes does not mean that Singapore is losing her national identity, but instead mark the progress of the nation. =)
rangoo_sg
2006-07-21 03:26:33 UTC
A simple matter really. The buildings of old are a sharp contrast to the structures of new. Rather than being focused on what we once were, most are now propelled to search for what we may become. History reminds us of momentous events that shaped the making of our country. As such when one takes a breather and lets life whiz past him, he can appreciate the impact such events have had in preserved historical buildings and monuments. A momentary respite but one that may help him learn from the mistakes of our ancestors if he takes the effort to delve deeper into our roots.



As for national identity however, it's a perception. No one seems to have same level of patriotism or the same sort of national identity as another. Ironical isn't it? Historial buildings and monuments may provide the foundation for our perceptions but in today's world, national identity is a moot point. The world is just another global village. Cultures are blurred against the ever increasing expansion of western civilisation.



We're known as a materialistic society to the rest of the world. How does that translate into national identity related to historical buildings? Our country is what we make it to be. The past is for remembrance but the culture that it promoted once is rapidly vanishing into the murky depths of time. Our national identity is the pride we have in the country for having made it this far.
sparkle1272001
2006-07-21 02:30:51 UTC
A historical building or monument would have been built because of an event or in recognition of an event that took place in Singapore's history. Recognising the event and understanding it will help us identify with these structures and remind us or our past history on this island.



Religious buildings like temples, churches and mosque, that are scattered all over the island may be considered historical, as they have played a part in our ancestors establishing that area of the community in which it was built in. These places of worship identifies Singapore as being a multi-racial society.



However, it is also important not to look mainly at historical structures, but at our modern ones as well. Our CBD skyline and buildings like The Esplanade Theatres At The Bay (similar to the Sydney Opera House), help identify Singapore as the cosmopolitan centre of South-East Asia and that little red dot in the world to be reckoned with - a place, as Singaporeans, otherwise known to us as home.
mr_mayat
2006-07-20 20:56:58 UTC
Historical Building & monuments binds Singaporeans to each other at an emotional level. So, even if everyone has a different background, this historical buildings represents a place where everyone shares a common re-collection. In a way, these places becomes a a reference point of Singaporeans' collective identity.

These buildings have to evoke a sense of nostalgia to every Singaporeans. Buildings like the old National Library, the Capitol Building and even the National Stadium (Those glorius Malaysia Cup days!) will remind Singaporeans where their lives had intertwined with each other.
2006-07-23 04:17:13 UTC
They remind us of our roots, where we came from, how we evolved in our newfound home, and how we'd like our lives to me like.

Many of the monuments in Singapore are actually places of worship. Therefore, these buildings are a mark of our country's proud multi-cultural heritage, and they symbolise the value that Singaporeans put on harmony albeit differences.

Singapore is a global city due to comprehensive urban planning and redevelopment to develop a thriving metropolis.





historical buildings and monuments in Singapore are essential to provide continuity, charm and character to Singapore's distinctiveness amidst the modern world of change and innovation



Singapore faces the task to identify which buildings and monuments are most worthy of preservation while it moves forward to build a new and distinctive skyline.

they remaind us where we born and where we come from our born in inthe world stomuch

Historical buildings and monuments contributes to our national identity in the visual aspect. Something that we can actually see and say "Hey, that's where my forefathers used to work!". It provides us with the rustic feeling and charms visitors, thus allowing visitors and citizens alike to feel that this nation is not 'new' and that this country has had its roots grown for decades/centuries. But if we were to bulldoze ALL historical monuments/buildings, does it mean we have no more national identity?
Sher K
2006-07-23 05:36:18 UTC
Historical Buildings and Monuments speak themselves of Singapore's past and depict the true cultural and social heritage. These monuments and Buildings are like an open book which can be read by locals and tourist alike at any moment and analyse the past history in comparison to the prevailing lifestyles and modern history.
wifiduhfylis
2006-07-20 23:15:46 UTC
OK since this is not a fun question...there won't be a fun answer.



To better answer the question, best to deconstruct the question to understand what the point is.



National identity. As with all sorts of identities...whether you're Mr ABC or an IT professional or mother of XYZ...these are all identities which are constructed by people, by society.



Which means that identity is not cast in stone and unchangeable forever.



So really national identity refers to what the powers that be want for their countrymen to think of themselves. With a change in power, national identities can also swiftly change. The point is this is a perception that is created and bred to become truth, or taken to be a non-disputable fact.



Which brings us to the point that what exactly qualifies as historical buildings or monuments that deserve to be preserved. Historical in my books refers to anything old...from the past. It doesn't necessarily have to have any value.



So again, what makes "historical" is based on the judgement of the powers to be. It involves a lot of filtering.



History is never really what it is, unless we're there to witness it. A lot of it should be forgotten and never remembered. And so it is usually with this sort of attitude that historians/powers that be define our history.



For Singapore, we've lots of colonial buildings that have been preserved. This goes to show that the powers that be are proud of our colonial past and any connections that may enhance our position in the world. We've also preserved places of worships to reflect the multi-cultural, multi-racial society that the powers that be are trying to maintain.



History...historical monuments and buildings...anything historical that's preserved is done so to perpetuate a "value" that should be preserved.



So, you wonder why kelongs and kampungs are not so top priority on our preservation list...it just shows that it's not of that much a value to enhance Singapore as a nation to be reckoned with :)
nero osyris
2006-07-20 21:25:40 UTC
Singapore is a unique country in the sense that we don't have a defining identity as yet. While I was working for my Fillipino employers they asked me what makes us Singaporean and I had to think a while before I could come up with an answer. Singapore, in her early years, was a great opportunity for immigrants with promises of a better life and as such there were a lot of immigrants from China, India and nearby Malaysia. There were also our British colonial masters. They would then form the backbone of our society as the four main races in Singapore: Chinese, Malays, Indians and Eurasians. And in Singapore we have places that represent these different races, such as Chinatown for the Chinese, and Little India for the Indians. Such buildings and monument served as a reminder that we all once came together from different places to meet in Singapore and eventually live together and with each other.



Unlike in the Phillipines, where my employers told me they were mainly Catholics, we do not have a so called dominant religion. We have Christians, Buddhists, Muslims and many other religions and so many colourful places of worship unique to each religion. The best part is that sometimes they're right next to each other, which says a lot about our religious tolerance which we Singaporeans sometimes take it for granted.



When we look at these historical buildings and monuments they remind us of our history of our ancestors from different places with different cultures living in harmony. They are also testament that different races can coexist with minimal racial and religious prejudices and such diversity in different cultures is what makes us uniquely Singaporean.
Nicholas k
2006-07-22 19:39:39 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments should be around for the young and future generations and tourist of the world to see and learn the history of it.The architectural and structure of the building is so rich in history and the amazing ways in constructing it during the olden days.It can never be replace with the modern technologies of construction.The designs and patterns are real craftsmanship compared to the modern constructions which are massed.There is no personal touch.Living in the modern days now,it's so irony that they are taking away olden buildings but building the new ones with the British colony touch.Why is this so when we have the real ones in our own land filled with so much history?Instead of looking into black and white photos,why not conserved some of it for our future generations?Singapore took a very long and painful ways to be what we are now.A modern country.The roots must be kept somehow.
angelica_rcn
2006-07-22 11:55:14 UTC
Old buildings should be conserved because these buildings are so worthy, beautiful and awesome and this where also all Singapore's pastare lying.Old buildings help us remember our history by showing us how do these buildings keep all of people's emotion like joy,sorrow and grief during the old days.

Picture tells a thousand word.Even we look only to these historical site's picture it can tell us so much about Singapore and to all the people who lives in this country.

These sites tells the whole world how singaporeans conserve all these historical buildings for such a long time until now, how emotional singaporeans are and how they discipline themselves.That's how these site contrbute to our national identity.
Firehose
2006-07-21 06:58:10 UTC
I would say that it only helps to educate the present and future generations of our forefathers who had toiled to make what Singapore is what it is today. Furthermore, it will help to evolve a sense of national identity in them.

The historical buildings such as mosques, temples, churches, hospitals, memorials, etc, helps to portray early Singaporeans efforts to make Singapore prosper. Some Singaporeans may say that Singapore has no national building or monument taht we can be proud of, nothing is prominent, we don't have buildings such as the Big Ben in London, Eiffel Tower in Paris or Opera House in Sydney, to really show "This is Singapore".

But, I beg to differ. Where else in the world that you can find places of worship for different religion in close proximity (Waterloo Street / Bencoolen Street area where you can find church, mosque, temples and synagogue within a few hundred metres of each other). And that should be our national identity 'a tolerant society'.

We have our own national identity, we have history in our historical buildings to show our toils. These old buildings also reminded Singaporeans that in the past we bow to a ruler a thousand miles away. And this same buildings will also remind the future generation that not to let history repeats itself.
simple
2006-07-23 04:45:19 UTC
They reminded us of our nationality that comes from all walks of life, example some of our ancestors are from China, India, Malaysia, Europe and American

They consist of the statue of Sir Stamford Raffles,; the place he stayed at Fort Canning. The Merlion (translated as Land of the lion) was first spotted by

Sang Nila Utama and the statue of a lion head and a fish tail is because during those days, people depend on catching fishes as their lively hood.



Chinatown still remain but just conserved the outlook to remind us of our Chinese foreigner whom had gathered there.



Last but not least, all the historical buildings and monuments in Singapore have had certainly contributed a huge tourist attraction here.
2006-07-21 03:00:42 UTC
Historical Buildings grew with the nation. They witness the rise and fall of the nation. For us, the buildings could stay with us through World War 2, independence and so on. For many of the elderly, the historical buildings formed many of the memories of their country. For the young ones, the monuments also relate to them the story of singapore. Each building is like a story book , with a rich local story to tell. Regardless of race, language or religion, all the people are familiar with such structures, the statue of Raffles, Merlion etc. They are symbolic of our country, and people relate to them when they think of singapore. Because these monuments are so representative of certain key events that happened in our country's nations, they are easily related to the country and contribute to the national identity.
Terence H
2006-07-20 23:30:10 UTC
Before one asks a question about architecture and identity one has to ask what exactly is the Singaporean national identity? Is it one that we choose to have a selective memory over, or one that is determined by history books? Does it go all the way back to fables of lion-spotting and crown-in-sea tossing? Deciding on what stories and text that shape our national identity in turn determines what architecture we as a society choose to contribute to that national identity.



But that would take too much time, so let's decide that our Singaporean national identity could, for now, include our immigrant culture, multi-ethnicity, colonial past, war memories and our hope for the future. To that extent, historical buildings and monuments act as markers of each phase (or moment) of the country's history. They are material objects that tell stories without speaking. And it's not just the building per se or its architecture. Each scar, each broken item can also add to the richness of the story.



Also, because of our heritage as an immigrant nation, and our constant push for progress, much of our national identity will involve a look towards the future. That, in itself, means that historical buildings and monuments are only partially sufficient as a contribution to national identity. Our contemporary buildings, our modern monuments to modern heroes must also share a place alongside the established cultural icons, so that as whole we are reminded of our past, and directed to the future.
2006-07-20 21:35:59 UTC
I'm sorry I haven't read your books. But I have visited Singapore. I guess the thing I think of most is Raffles.

One can still take a lovely afternoon tea there, with all the elegance of the old and leisurely English world. One can still crunch the peanut shells as Somerset Maugham did there. It's all pale now, I suppose. There aren't any great writers that I know of hanging out there now. But they were a part of what made a sense of colonial England.



That sense of Englishness still holds in the way that guests are handled in hotels in Singapore. You can still order a pot of Horlicks before turning in for the night.



I suppose, despite the variety of ethnic groups living togethe in Singapore, the influence of the English is there still, and there is a tie to history that I like.



This may sound snobby, but I think the English influence elevated Singapore and is something to be proud of.



I'm sorry, I'm not very good at saying what I feel.
kc_always
2006-07-23 09:51:44 UTC
Our national identity is made up of the diverse cultures and past influences. The historical buildings and monuments played a part because they enforced the various cultures and past influences that Singapore had. The historical sites served as a reminder as to what we are in the past and the future.
minerva
2006-07-22 09:20:45 UTC
Each historical buildings and monuments in Singapore tells a story of how Singapore came to be. They contribute to our national identity because with these stories, it allows each new generation to understand the past, and from understanding the past, learn from the mistakes made and appreciate what our forefathers has done for Singapore.
2006-07-22 09:12:34 UTC
By preserving our historical buildings and monuments, it helps by reminding us of our past. Fort Canning Park or Kranji War Memorial will make us remember WW2 when Singapore was invaded by Japan. These will also educate the future generations, and they will get to see living pictures instead of just textbooks. As a result, it will be made known that our national identity has been forged by our ancestors. In addition, it will show them what was Singapore like then and now.
2006-07-21 01:56:09 UTC
Every building and monument tells a story of the different lives that have crossed paths in this divered community was back. They have distinguishing features in their designs from different races and live to tell the tale of the many people from another country who have travelled across so many miles to come to singapore and set up their lives and bring their culture, enfussing it along with oter cultures as well, setting Singapore uniquely diveresed and yet united. We may tell a tourist that there's malay, there's the chinese, the indians,the eurasians and so on, but we're all singaporeans and we share each other's knowledge thus our identity...

and you won't find it anywhere else but in Singapore. You won't find the merlion or the central firestation in any other place and if you see it in a postcard, it says SINGAPORE
bussetter
2006-07-21 01:53:57 UTC
well, historical buildings and monuments are old. if they could talk they would probably talk non stop about the things that they have seen happened and they have survived the years. just by looking at the buildings and monuments, we might be able to tell what happened during that period of time. when tourists come to singapore and visit these place, they gain some insight to how singapore was created from the past and why we are so successful today.
Chinster
2006-07-20 19:56:03 UTC
Singapore is ever progressing and these historical momuments allow us to see how far we have come from then till now. In the world there should also be harmony between the old and the new, we must always look to the future and keep building on but we need these monuments to remind us, hey this is where and how we started and these are our roots, so that we will never stray from our believes.
2014-09-30 02:24:45 UTC
Buildings which reflects the colonial government which ruled the country. Districts where different ethnic groups lived. These show us the living lifestyle of the people who use to live or work in them.



Monuments are for us to remember a person or an event which had huge impact in our national history. A statue of Sir Standford Raffles, the founder of the modern Singapore, the Coastal Defence sites that are littered around the Island. Fort Siloso of Sentosa. These are all reminders of People and Events.
AmigoEva
2006-07-23 02:41:00 UTC
Many historical buildings and monuments remind us of our heritage and how our forefathers have struggled to make Singapore what she is today.



Those of racial backgrounds emphasise that Singapore is a multi-racial society and that it wasn’t that easy to have reached what we are today, taking into account the many racial riots that happened in the past.



Those of religion backgrounds show us that Singapore is of different religion and reminds us that the missionaries were important in spreading the importance of education to the locals in the past.



Those of defence backgrounds makes us remember that Singapore has a long history of being ruled by other overlords and not forgetting WWII, where lives of many were being sacrificed. This will make us treasure that fact that we are having a much more peaceful life than in the past.
Sockalingam L
2006-07-23 02:20:33 UTC
It serves more as a nostalgic rememberance to the Singapore community especoially to the younger generations where they can appreciate the national monument and identity.



This is because currrently our Singapore society is slowly forgetting the historical values of Singapore and the current education needs to put the importance to it.
2006-07-21 06:30:00 UTC
Having historical buildings around Singapore helps us to remember our past and our identity.



Our modern identity may be that of a growing, thriving, cosmopolitian city BUT our true identity is that of a nation who made it from fishing port to world class city.



having the monuments around serve as tangible reminders of Singapores past and the hardships of our ancestors. Every landmark tells a story of a particular group of immigrants and their toil and troubles.



The landmarks also showcase our multi-cultural background because they tell a collective story of people from all different races immigrating to Singapore to try to find a better life.



it is important that today's and future generations know and realise what it took for Singapore to get where it is today so that they will not take what we have forgranted and also have a better idea of what being Singaporean is truly about.
Wen Hwee
2006-07-22 20:02:58 UTC
Historical buildings is part of our history. Architectures reflect the different eras that Singapore have gone through For example, The Subordinate courts, Parliament house reflect the early days when we were part of the British colonies. Following that, the different style of the building at various places reflects the period of time whereby our forefathers, the immigrant workers at then, were segregated according to race. (Malays at the Eunos, geylang area, Chinese at the Chinatown area etc). This bring to light the racial riots in the 1950s. This not only reflects the inadequancies of segregating races but only brings out the importance of integrating the different races together.



In addition, the religious buildings form part of our rich heritage. The Sultan mosque, Shuang Lin Monastery, Sri Mariamman Temple all reflects the beliefs that our forefathers brought along with them when they came to Singapore.



Our World war II monuments remind us of the importance of self-reliance and the cruelty of wat. We can only count on ourselves to defend our country, and in unity, regardless of race.



Looking at the past gives us a glimpse of how did we arrive at the current modernised Singapore. The historical buildings gave an insight into the life of our forefathers, the new buildings beside them gave us the dimension of how we have developed and transformed as a nation to the present Singapore, the foundation laid by our forefathers and the cumulative efforts by the next generations.



Historical buildings are important for they help us identify where we came from, how did we arrive here. Just like the Germans who recognised their history, the historical buildings in Singapore should be conserved as it reminds us of our past and allow us to reflect on our present. It also give us hope that we will do well in the future, if we continue the entrepreneur spirit of our forefathers. This is our National Identity.



In conclusion, historical buildings are part of our heritage, telling us where we came from, how did we get here and how do we go from here to the future- Our National Identity. It offers significant lessons on how we should be as a nation, the importance of racial harmony and unity and should be conserved.
pollyanna
2006-07-21 17:35:25 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments in Singapore are not just reminders of how we have developed as a nation, they also provide insight into our current national psyche. Our past can and do affect our present and future. Thus, how we, as a nation, behave and act presently is tied to our history for e.g the idea of Singaporeans having 'colonial hang-ups' - we were once a colonized country and this can be seen in our buildings and yes, they should be preserved because they are key to understanding ourselves.
2006-07-21 13:12:32 UTC
Singapore was founded in 1819. It has gone through centuries till what it is today. The old, historical buildings and monuments are histories and memories of what we have gone through over the years. As most of the historical buildings and monuments are of different culture, religion and race, it simply reflects that we live in harmony with all different religion. These buildings project Singapore as a multi racial country where different races can live peacefully with one another
Jason T
2006-07-21 10:28:18 UTC
Dear readers, it's good that Singapore is the most advanced in technologies and the modernised environment among the South East Asia.



Singapore was once founded by Sir Stamford Raffles and still it was governed by British. Those buildings can show tourists and teach them that not only can catch these historical english buildings in UK but in Singapore too.



But still we have to preserve some historical buildings as during early times, most of them were hands built by hard working samsui women. Do respect their hard sweat job and it took years to build up and it takes months to demolish it.



Do consider the hard work and not the look.
Alvin X
2006-07-21 06:13:48 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments serve as 'living, breathing' reminders of Singapore's journey to nationhood. A national identity is an ever-evolving thing that is hard to define, but we can begin to arrive at an understanding of it when we look back at these buildings and see for ourselves the changes we have undergone between then and now.



But that is only half the story; we musn't neglect the human stories that reside in those buildings and mouments, for they are what made those buildings worth of being historical in the first place. These heroes of Singapore's past may no longer be around, but we have these buildings and monuments to remind us of their deeds in their stead.



Looking around us, I see the old colonial buildings, the various cultural villages our immigrant elders were split into under Sir Stamford Raffles' town planning and all the sites documenting the ravages of World War II, and I sense a nation that overcame the divisiveness of its colonial master's policies, survived the hardships of occupation and eventually rid itself of colonialism to become the model city-state it is today. Racially harmonious, industrious, perservering, courageous and incorruptable: these are the characteristics of our national identity I see defined by our historical buildings and monuments.
Team D3
2006-07-21 03:38:49 UTC
These buildings and monuments registered some foot-prints in the evolution of Singapore. They capture certain historical moment, sight, with the unique background on that special time and space. Through these buildings and monuments, national identities then can can build up through generations.
xxon_23
2006-07-21 03:26:48 UTC
The conservation of historical buildings and monuments is an important step the government has taken. It reminds us of our coloiurful past.



Take for example, the Istana Kampong Glam. I was still in primary school when it had undergone a major facelift and my heart is filled with pride whenever I am in the vicinity! Imagine passing by a "castle" when you are on your way to eat murtabak and briyani rice at Zam Zam's!



If there had been no plans to conserve our rather many historical sites, all would be lost and Singaporeans would be "a lost bunch of people", rootless and have nothing to identify with.
AZAHAR A
2006-07-21 00:28:42 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments in Singapore are like postcards.It depicts the memories of the local scene. depending on the era.Many of these historical building and monuments were from the British colonial period and the Japanese Occupation.

These buildings and monuments sites are the testimony of what Singapore and its people,Malay,Chinese,Indians, Eurasians and others, had gone thru the yesteryear's of being colonised by the British and occupied by the Japanese and finally thru the struggle in achieving its Independence.

Multi racial we are,these brings out the sense of belonging in every Singaporean of what our ancestors had built thru the years.

'ROME WASNT BUILT IN A DAY". Lets not forget our heritage, preserve these buildings and monuments. There's a old Malay saying, 'Your home is where the sky is above and your feets touch the ground".
jtlg78
2006-07-20 19:06:08 UTC
1. Its the proof of our ancestors existence and contribution in making what Singapore is today.



2. A country with a history worth telling the world of its glorious.



3. Keeping history will tell our future Singaporeans more of the county they in.



4. Last of all, these historical buildings and monuments worth a lot of money. HAHAHAHAHHA
Apis
2006-07-20 18:39:59 UTC
National identity per se is undefinable and we cannot pinpoint a specific thing/word/item and say that is our national identity. Different aspects like buildings (historical/modern), culture, societal norms/not norms, just to name a few, are what makes our national identity.



Historical buildings and monuments contributes to our national identity in the visual aspect. Something that we can actually see and say "Hey, that's where my forefathers used to work!". It provides us with the rustic feeling and charms visitors, thus allowing visitors and citizens alike to feel that this nation is not 'new' and that this country has had its roots grown for decades/centuries. But if we were to bulldoze ALL historical monuments/buildings, does it mean we have no more national identity? Of course not!



So, it's all part of a package of many aspects and that each aspect complements one another to form what we deem as National Identity.
Duchess
2006-07-23 04:33:23 UTC
They provide the link to our country's history & culture of our people & it's also very very important in generating the tourism and big factor in contributing to our country's economy. We also have our government to thank for their preservation works on Spore's history because tourists want to see things they can't see in their own country.

Nobody wants to visit a country which is so modernized, just like their own country, and at the end of day with no fond memories whatsoever of the place they've visited nor the people.

Moreover, with our historical bldgs & monuments, visitors will come to know how far Spore has come to be what it is today; the many many generations before our time & their complete & unselfish contributions to the country & having multicultural people living under the same rule in peace & respecting each other's place of worship.
lostgal
2006-07-23 06:17:21 UTC
Being in a multi-racial country, these historical buildings are really important as it not only reflects the harmony between the different races depite the different culture and the disputes that arises. It also remind us of the hardwork that our forefathers has put in to keep this country going. From this buildings and monuments, we will be reminded of the past, learn from it and not do it again. Also, it keeps our nation going strong and our pride will not sway because we have gone far and success is in our hands eventhough we are a small nation.

Did i tell you that this historical buildings helps to attract tourist due to its interesting background? =D
sugar.peace
2006-07-22 08:37:18 UTC
The difference between the historical structures and the current landscape of skyscrapers tells a story of a country who has come a long way.



The historical buildings and monuments is a reminder to all Singaporeans and tourists that Singapore is a country who has an indomitable spirit, who perserveres against all odds and proves her detractors wrong.
englishbreakfastea
2006-07-21 09:18:28 UTC
I think these old buildings are conserved at great cost because they remind us of the history and what our ancestors went through years not so long ago (but seemed like forever). Places such as the Emerald Hill, the shop houses at Blair road and the five foot ways at Amoy Street, one can only imagine how life was - bustling as always but less high-tech. It would be too sterile and boring if all the buildings in Singapore are new.
Lucifer
2006-07-21 07:37:09 UTC
Historical buildings like the Raffles landing, Empress place, Andrew's cathedral, Supreme court, Raffles hotel, and the Singapore art museum are "unique" and cannot be found anywhere else in the world. These buildings cannot be rebuilt when they are demolished. That is why we must preserve these historical buildings. It reminds us of what our predecessors have went through to be united today. To be a multi-racial country. To have peace instead of war. Monuments such as the lion symbolises the blooming economy of our country. It symbolises growth and fertility. The technological advances of our country. And most of all, we will remember those who have gave their lives in the past in order to give us a better life...
kangaroo
2006-07-20 20:34:08 UTC
Physical objects normally leave stronger and greater impression of a country. No one read the history not unless for test or interest. Historical buildings and monuments are reflection of our past, and preserved to show descendants and visitors how our forefathers has strive and work hard to build the nation. As such, we must cherished what we have and be proud what a small nation can achieved.
seasoned tea
2006-07-20 19:40:57 UTC
Don't think they contribute much to our identity.



We don't think of the old National Library and think that's our national identity, do we? I guess culture and everything else but buildings and monuments contribute to a national identity.



Historical buildings and monuments probably serves as a reminder to our nation's past and adds colour to the city facade. Then again, there's not much historical buildings and monuments left with all the funny refurbishment that has been done to all the old buildings.
rainbow
2006-07-20 18:53:54 UTC
Very very important. Eg., old National Library (red brick building), the old Fullerton building (high ceiling cooling eerie feeling), all gave the impression of a pre-modernised Singapore before, some history to reflect upon, some stories you can tell to you kids when you bring them there. Now, even if I bring my kids to the new Fullerton Building and tell them it used to be a post office, they will not be able to comprehend or appreciate the history behind it. Sadly, Singapore is just a city with no identity now. I with the authorities will not destroy our "history and heritage" any further.
Jia Xian
2006-07-21 13:32:48 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments serve as important markers in the various chapters of our collective history, of both Singapore and her people. In the midst of modern, contemporary development, such conserved historical buildings can be places where people can connect to their experiences in the past, where the old can narrate stories to the young. Our diverse culture and heritage can then be communicated in more concrete means than through viewing photographs or texts.



Even as some of these historical buildings have been renovated to accommodate new uses, the very existence of these spaces allows the present and future generations to adapt such spaces to their relevant, contemporary uses and continually add layers of meaning and narratives to enrich the spirit of the place.



The old and new coexist, allowing us to appreciate the diversity in the history and culture of the city, thereby enriching our collective experience of the city. A rich national identity is born.
tickle_shoes87
2006-07-23 05:55:51 UTC
"History" --> His Story



As most people had said, it reminds us of our roots and heritage, where do our forefathers come from. Historical buildings and monuments are there to constantly remind us of our roots no matter what happens or how developed and westernizen Singapore may be now.



It is always good to take a look back at our history, seeing how much we had progress from the pass and most importantly, learning from our mistakes in the past.



No matter how far you are out there, the Merlion is always there to remind you: "Hey, I'm from Singapore".
leonglipwee
2006-07-22 19:16:45 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments must be kept because without them, no matter how long the history a country has, it will have nothing to remember of his past. As a country progress important architecture/monument that depicts the ideology, technology, era should be kept as a reminder of how a nation has progress and inflict a sense of nationalist among the people. With them, we will always be a infant compared to countries like China, Great Britain, USA, Russian, Europe .... etc. They always be great because history are marked and kept and progress with them.



And lastly from commercial point of view. One of our main country's economic contributor is tourist. We can have great tourist attractions like huge mall, amusement park, zoo. These can be easily duplicated at another country. But no one can mimic a country's history that are the long time unique attraction for tourist
Chickadee
2006-07-22 09:46:45 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments are real physical records of our past. Destroying them means leaving nothing for our future children to learn about and appreciate what our fore fathers have done. Every landmark tells a story. Great way to preserve and conserve the old buildings and monuments is to "blend" or "knit" them into our existing architecture. Examples include the the old shop houses turned into Parco Bugis shopping mall, old General Post Office into Fullerton Hotel.
Catwoman
2006-07-22 01:27:13 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments do contribute to our national identity. It protrays where, when and how everything started. They are there for us to look back and ponder. Sentimental values it is too for these precious monuments and historical buildings were even there before some of us are born into this world. They could be of a great use in future, in terms of historical education or defence.Tourist attraction bringing revenue to our country.
acjj
2006-07-20 22:53:25 UTC
With the decreasing number of historical buildings, I strongly feel that historical buildings and monuments in Singapore should be conserved. This will serve as an education purpose for the upcoming generations as well as tourists attractions.



Old buildings should be conserved as closely as possible in their original state, without losing its orignal identity.



Our historical sites remind us of the history, our origins, the hard work our forefathers have been through, and will definitely trigger lots of fond memories. E.g. a stroll down Boat Quay reminds me of my younger days when I saw lots of labourer tad in their singlets and shorts, with a towel hung around their neck, carrying sacks of rice from the boats to the warehouses. This sight is still fresh in my mind whenever I walk past Boat Quay though it is now filled with pubs and restaurants.
happinessfish
2006-07-21 18:38:02 UTC
We are too young a nation to have the experience to conserve our national identity, however, we have started. We have historical buildings such as the National Theather, which was torn down. SO SAD!, the whole stretch of Bukit Timah, now converted to High rise condo area etc., Can we keep one of the oldest Hawker center to show our cultural heritage before converting them to "air-con" eating houses, GOD knows when!

Our historical building and monuments do tell of Multi Racial Harmony which is still existing.
Pearl_Dexing
2006-07-21 17:27:38 UTC
Sometime it is not so much about building that makes an Singaporean Identity. It's the people at that time who change history and landscape that make what Singapore is today. And with this piece of history or building, the young will see, appreciate and remember the beauty, sweat and toils of our founders.
Andre S
2006-07-21 03:54:50 UTC
historical buildings and monuments are objects that is seen daily by people and the unique architectures depicts certain important events or people in the past.Thus by preserving historical buildings and monuments in Singapore, it actually helps people to see or imagine people in the past and what was life like in the past just by seeing it.Our national identity is something which is not created overnight,but it is started all the way back to the past when Sir Stanford Raffles came to Singapore until now.therefore the buildings and monuments are evidence of our national identity.
venkatraman k
2006-07-20 22:49:52 UTC
Singapore is a global city still the old monuments will give a feeling of ancient city.Historical buildings and monuments in Singapore are essential to prove that different culture/races could live happily together.This will be a attraction to Singapore's Visitors with different personilities,culture,etc., will make them to feel like home.
paddington123
2006-07-20 20:19:08 UTC
To me, historical buildings gives u a sense of the past that verify national events and history..it is a physical object that is existent to aid its people's understanding of their environment.



As individuals, we question our identity,... how we came to earth and what is the meaning of life..., these historical buildings and monuments tell us stories that we can relate to.. telling us that this is indeed us and how we belong in the community. They can educate you a lesson or two on the mistakes that was made before you came along and for you to learn of it consequences.



In sentimental terms, places remind you of certain events in your personal growth..these are the memories that make u who u are, and how you've become so. You will pass these memories down to your bloodline and affect them infinitely.



Without the buildings and monuments, together with the effort to understand our past, we would always be starting from scratch and remain competitively behind other nationalities which have their historical records. When we come to learn of our identities and understand its strengths and shortcomings, we stand together to compete economically and survive effectively. So as to have a valuable voice in shaping the worlds of tomorrow, that affects our survival.
Freesky
2006-07-20 19:57:36 UTC
Each historical buildings and monuments are a representation of a story / event that occured in the past. These stories / events eventually lead to the formation of the current Singapore and our distinctive culture. National identity I believe, is referring to our own distinctive culture.
vaporixm
2006-07-20 19:14:02 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments are tangible reminders of Singapore past history. Being virtue of their physical presence, it conjures more vivid memories for those who lived through the events that happened as well as helps the later generations to imagine the events that happened better. Compare this to a historical event with no tangible remains, the former is more likely to be freshly remembered by the minds of the people as there is a physical reminder of the events that happened. Without any physical reminder, the people can only depend on various documented accounts of the events by different historians and if there is no effort to bring up such documentation or keep the memories of such events alive, most people are likely to be ignorant of such events and sadly as time passes by, they are likely to be forgotten or worse, ignored.

With knowledge and understanding of the history behind the building of our nation, we are able to appreciate the hardship it took to create a nation to call our own and be proud of our nation. Without such reminders of the past, history may be forgotten and nothing left for the future generations to identify with. Should that happen, our national identity would falter.

Hence, historical structures must be preserved. We owe it to the past generations, who endured the hardship creating our nation, to preserve their legacy for the future generations.
bloodbros2001
2006-07-22 09:00:30 UTC
They reminds us of the "Making of Singapore". How Singapura originated and how the nation have evolved into today's modern society. They, like our fore fathers, are the roots of our nation. The Statue of Liberty represents the United States, The Eiffel Tower symbolises Paris (France). Likewise, we have the Merlion, Boat Quay, Statue of Sir Stamford Raffles etc. These helps visitors/tourists remember Singapore. For Singaporeans, they reminds us of our history and life did not begin with a silver spoon
sid adam
2006-07-22 05:50:12 UTC
I think it makes us whole and unique. In every country how they lived defines who they are. The same is evident here in Singapore, our historical buildings and monuments shows a slice of life that we used to live.Like the colonial buildings from the times we where colonised by the British to the quayside longhouses where trading used to take place, to the mosques,temples and churches that showed our humble beginnings and how a piece of every society is brought together. Remembering how we started had help us to move forward and shape what we become... our identity - modern yet still rooted by our Asian heritage :)
Geo C
2006-07-21 03:26:58 UTC
I feel, it would contribute more to the property value than our national identity.

How many Singaporeans actually care about any historical buildings or monuments being tear down? Probably a fraction out of the 4.4million on the island. And that fraction would probably get no answer from anyone or (worse) blacklisted by the authority. *shiver*
2006-07-20 23:13:42 UTC
We build on the foundations that have been laid by our forefathers, so we should know their values and how they lived their lives. Old buildings help us to know these things, since our forefathers are already dead and gone. We can read historical documents, but not every society keeps records. Also, things written by people arent always accurate. Plus, buildings and monuments survive longer than paper :)

When we tear down all the old buildings without thought, we are erasing our history and our culture. Our younger generations wont know how their forefathers in Singapore used to live, what they believed in, what values were important to them. Without this knowledge, it's very hard to impart good lessons and values to our children because we have nothing much to refer to.
2006-07-20 18:42:25 UTC
As time goes by, historical buildings and monuments in Singapore naturally become national icons, like the Merlion, making them uniquely Singaporean. Therefore, these icons contribute to our national identity.
KnightFury
2006-07-23 09:18:12 UTC
Singapore is 1 place in the world which was founded for its strategic location and with it comes people of different cultures. Through the years of interaction with the "rojak" of customs and tradition, many have changed or taken a more Singaporean shape

by preserving these buildings and mounments, we can trace our roots to know what it was like before and how it become "Singapore Style"
SoNearYetSoFar
2006-07-22 19:50:51 UTC
It reminds us of our forefathers who worked so hard in the making of Singapore, and historical buildings and monuments make Singapore different from other countries. It lets Singaporeans feel proud of our forefathers who made Singapore one of the busiest ports in the world and made Singapore a great place to stay.
bertram189
2006-07-22 07:15:34 UTC
This historical buildings and monuments would show everyone how Singapore was before as the past few years that singapore went rhough so much troubles.

Therefore, we should keep this buildings and monuments as it speaks value to us and show how we, the next generation, can contribute..
BeBe
2006-07-21 20:51:04 UTC
They tell us about our past, remind us of our roots so that we don't get blind by our present culture now which is mostly influenced by other countries. They also make us learn from past mistakes so that we don't repeat them. City Hall would probably be the most meaningful place and bear the most important lessons for Singaporeans. Ceremonies marking Singapore's tumultuous past such as the Japanese unconditional surrender on 12 September 1945, announcement of Singapore's city status in 1951, proclamation of self-government in 1959 and independence in 1965, all took place there.
bb_biker2002
2006-07-21 04:55:40 UTC
The historical buidings, monuments, and even places (for example, the Japanese Landing Site at Punggol), have their own story to tell; a story behind why it was built in the first place. All of them function dormantly as pieces of a jig-saw puzzle, revealing a whole picture of how Singapore becomes what we are today.



PS: Just my 3-cents' worth :o)
sheila0923
2006-07-21 02:15:51 UTC
Historical building and monuments, you might say, are the chapters of the story of a country, such as Singapore. Historical buildings and monuments are constant reminder of our past and where we came from and what we are privilege to have and have been and still benefiting from.They are constant reminder and definition of what a true citizen of a country is. They are the triumphs as well as the scars of one country.
2006-07-21 01:48:33 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments should only be preserved if they symbolise our past achievements or has a story to tell of our past. They can then be converted into museums for all visitors, young and old, locals or foreigners to understand this is the heart and soul of our nation.



It is a waste to see our monuments lying in waste without any use or idea why they are preserved.
xuehuo
2006-07-20 18:49:35 UTC
It's the Happenings !



In the bygone era of history, we had lingered at various historical locations. Ideas , memory and stuggles were etched in those places.



Take the old Capitol building at City hall, there used to be a cinema there, it is where my parents had a date, whenever we are in the area, they would smile and comment (repeat : same words) "that's where we had our date" . *smiles*



In our short independence of 41 years, though we were in existance in the 1900s (from Sir Stanford Raffles time), we did not have a unique Singapore architechtural style.



We had borrowed extenstively from the various influences, it reinforced our national identity as a place where various ethic groups mix and live together.



woohoo !
daniel_yoong
2006-07-23 04:30:28 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments are like photo albums. They are what once was, and gives future generations the opportunity to see and perhaps, understand, the lives and times of the past. Just like we look at our old photos to look back at what we were, how things were and where we were....having historical buildings and monuments gives us that exact same opportunity.
2014-10-29 15:46:29 UTC
Monuments do contribute a great deal to our national identity. Have you ever been to City Hall on Saturdays? where you will find punks and skinheads loitering and hanging around? As we all know these minorities have their own origins and their own teachings. Yet these youngsters cannot adhere to those things being in a developed society.
Joshua Huang
2006-07-21 23:55:27 UTC
They contribute to our national identity because they are considered exact and accurate proof of how our forefathers' living conditions were like and what kind of spirit the buildings represented for our forefathers.



Take for example the Thian Hock Keng temple,it was a place where the immigrants of the Taoist faith flock to and congregate to pray to the gods for safety and also for getting togethers. This is just but one of the few monuments that stand testament to the kind of identity we have, what more if we include the Sultan Mosque and the Sri Mariammam Temple? :)
Ice K
2006-07-21 22:24:15 UTC
As we cast our sight on these historical monuments, we instinctively remember and become thankful for those who have gone before us, leaving behind a heritage for us. Such heritage comes in different forms like hard work, perseverance, diligence, wisdom, effectiveness and more importantly the courage to live out our vision!



We are then also reminded that this present generation now carry the baton and so set our vision on what lies ahead until it's our turn to pass this rich heritage on. Majullah Singapura !
2006-07-21 05:18:48 UTC
It reminds us of the hard work that our forefathers have done, and also to remind us that we are Singaporeans. These historical buildings and monuments also tell us about the history of Singapore, and the long way that it has come through.
michael2003c2003
2006-07-21 04:14:58 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments are, by their very nature, of historical significance and importance. They have lasted the test of time and are integral to national identity insofar as being part of the fabric of the physical landscape of Singapore. Those buildings and monuments carry with them tangible evidences of all those who have come before us as well as intangible evidences of what formed our 'national' identity in the past. While we have kept fountains and walkways and statues from our colonial past, they do no necessarily 'identify' us as in informing us where we came from, in our very young history and we could be going, in terms of nation building and forging for an overall common identity.
big head
2006-07-21 03:21:22 UTC
They remind us of the past and show the present and future generations of what had happened before. They also showcase the culture and architecture of the past. Some buildings or monuments may be named after famous people. All these help to build our national identity.
Busybody
2006-07-20 22:27:17 UTC
Just one building or one artifact will not define the nation's image. It is a collection of buildings, items, stories of people which will give insight of what the nation is like. Fort Siloso and other war memorial tell that our nation has participated in war, which may help part of our national service philosophy. A row of shophouses will tell the lives of our part generations. Each of these monuments will together contribute to what we are today.
sulphur
2006-07-20 20:32:08 UTC
Honestly, looking at all the historical buildings and monument speaks nothing except "the british were here". Kampongs, fishing village, kelongs they are the the true identity of Singapore.
FuNkY_GaL
2006-07-20 17:36:59 UTC
Singapore is a global city due to comprehensive urban planning and redevelopment to develop a thriving metropolis.





historical buildings and monuments in Singapore are essential to provide continuity, charm and character to Singapore's distinctiveness amidst the modern world of change and innovation



Singapore faces the task to identify which buildings and monuments are most worthy of preservation while it moves forward to build a new and distinctive skyline.
mossycheong
2006-07-23 06:35:22 UTC
the buildings reminds us of the history of singapore way before we were born. the different architecturual designs from the different communities let us understand each other better. some are to remember the world war II e.g kranji memorial, some are built by imigrants from all over the places e.g armenian church, some reflect the early lifes of singaporeans e.g chinatown. or even the ex post office that became a hotel e.g fullerton. without these buildings existence, our future generation will not be able to understand the different culture and the racial harmony of our society. in a way, the buildings are a educational tool for the past, present and future generation of singaporeans.
shasha_angellic
2006-07-22 06:10:34 UTC
It reminds us of how Singapore have struggled to get to the point where it stands today. It also shows us how our ancestors have struggled in the olden days. The historical buildings and monuments will reminds us of Singapore history.
2006-07-21 00:28:27 UTC
Remind us of what our great grander. it is also a prove tat those stuff exist when people in the new generation talk about it they no tat it true has it is a proof. some country has king in 2000 yrs ago and after 2000 yrs people might be talking about it some may say it fake but some may say it true so to see which is true, they need proof! any way u r living in the 70's as now there is no more malaya but Malaysia dude!(im a s' porean)
2006-07-22 19:15:38 UTC
Time pass, people change but history doesn't.



These buildings contains the richness of our heritage in Singapore. They also represent significant period of change in building Singapore. These buildings are more than just a building built of bricks and mortar, they are also collective memories as a citizen of Singapore
mervz
2006-07-22 13:01:24 UTC
Our city does not have much historical place like other country but these few building witness the much history our city has been thru and thus it serve as a reminder and also historical data to our people to never forget our past
BoM
2006-07-22 15:51:45 UTC
Many of the monuments in Singapore are actually places of worship. Therefore, these buildings are a mark of our country's proud multi-cultural heritage, and they symbolise the value that Singaporeans put on harmony albeit differences.
.·´¯`»FarZalie«·´¯`·.
2006-07-21 18:10:16 UTC
I think old buildings should be conserved because they help us remember our history.They remind us about our roots and where we came from.They remind us about our encestors.They remind us about our multi racials and multi cultural society~Then and now.



At least let our younger generations see what were Singapore like, before.With that they can learn and have more pictures about it.Let them value the unique architectural of our historical building like The National Theatre.

We just can't be proud of new tall and stiff building without it's own character.



I think we can't just simply erase our history!
life_time
2006-07-21 10:13:21 UTC
Historical buildings were our fellow citizens' forefather had built, also it shown their effort of commitment to society in the earliest day. To conserve its not just for historical purpose but it also let the Singaporeans have a sense of belonging.. and remind us to keep continue building up commitment spirit to make a better future.
ani ram
2006-07-21 09:13:10 UTC
historical building plays an important part in singaporean life. we can trace back ones root by these building. the arch of Nanyang (NTU) is a sample olden days. The indian temple at China town show that racial harmony in those days. you can see an indian temple, chinese temple, mosque and church are at along the road. empress place we have a lot of monuments eg. lim boon keng, sir stamford raffles. At city hall we could notice indian seaboy monument and cvilis who die in world war. our melion and shop houses and some schools. Now kids have to go fort canning hil to see the canoes which were used in war and also the stone pillar of government officers. At Kranji memorial wall you can see those Austriallian amy troope who were kill in world war two and also our previous presidents tmob stone. that all i can think now.
Catchaworm
2006-07-21 09:01:30 UTC
The older the better. Couldn't be more precise. New buildings although clean, modern and pleasant, cannot evoke that sense of nostalgia or even an era gone by. It's a feeling, something to be savoured, like a good cuppa on a peaceful afternoon.
2006-07-21 04:03:49 UTC
We conserve buildings and construct monuments, i.e. Memories at Old Ford Factory museum at Bukit Timah Road (venue of the British surrender to Japan in WW2), to mark their significance in our storied past.



We preserve areas, like Syed Alwi with all its Transitional and Late styled shophouses, because they chronicle our architectural history and showcase our melange of influences.



We restore decrepit buildings such as temples (Thian Hock Keng), mosques (Sultan) and churches (St Andrew's Cathedral) to remind us of our diverse cultural roots.



All these are physical markers of the bygone time of our forefathers, and their walls or pavements record our multi-cultural history. We should appreciate the uniqueness of our 'rojak' (hodgepodge) society that is our national identity. Only in Singapore.
2006-07-21 02:36:00 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments contributes to our national identity in the visual aspect. Something that we can actually remember those days how they build and provides us with the rustic feeling and charms visitors, thus allowing visitors and citizens alike to feel that this nation is not 'new' and that this country has had its roots grown for decades/centuries.
absinth
2006-07-20 23:08:14 UTC
We need to know who we were to have a benchmark when we think of who we want to become. Old buildings show us a way of life that used to be, of how people lived and worked. Monuments show us what used to be important to our people once upon a time. It helps us plan into the future - should what was important in the past continue to be important to us? Or should we move on to other values and ways of life?
Xanana
2006-07-20 07:50:59 UTC
Many of the monuments in Singapore are actually places of worship. Therefore, these buildings are a mark of our country's proud multi-cultural heritage, and they symbolise the value that Singaporeans put on harmony albeit differences.
Matthew W
2006-07-23 07:09:24 UTC
It shows that many things happened in Singapore in the past and that there were many people who did good things for this country which has made Singapore what it is today. This is something that we can be proud.
iangoh1964
2006-07-22 21:25:20 UTC
By the architecture, one can appreciate that period of history's influence upon the country/colonial history, and likely cultural adptation. By the location, one can establish the population mix, spread, and values. But by the local stories or folklores, one can also ascertain religious beliefs, practices, mores. Lastly it may even be possible via recorded historical events, to coincide and discern fact from fiction of certain happenings or cross-roads of timed event.
zrowx
2006-07-22 20:16:27 UTC
Its the only connection to our past. A lot more than a photo album, we can feel it. It constantly reminds us of the change, providing a contrast with the present building.



Its the only heirloom left behind by our forefathers. They built a nation's success and left a memory lane for us to remember. Let's cherish these priceless treasures forged on this lovely island.
ben_por
2006-07-21 10:42:58 UTC
buildings age like wine, they bring a flavour that can never be expressed in words. they remind us that even with all the advancement and money, some things just cannot compare to what has stood the test of time. without them, we'd just be the practical generation that we've been taught to become. now we have an excuse for romanticism and heritage, sentimentality and having something to remember the good old days by. which come to think of it... one day, our HDBs will be historical buildings.
hemant
2006-07-21 06:32:25 UTC
Contribution of monuments and historical buildings in Singapore can be judged and felt with the history associated with it. the prehistoric civilisations, traditional practise and culture provide multilateral promotion in diversified field, tourism can be taken as example.

they are our natural heritage which are greatest assets to our country as they determine the growth and development from the time we were invaded, got independence and period when we traced the ladder of development to categorised into developed nations of the world. As "Old is Gold", what we are today is of what we did yesterday, if we forget the contribution of ancient period, its quiet predictable that we along with our remarkable progress will be overlooked tomorrow.
putydog79
2006-07-21 02:16:26 UTC
The history and story behind each historical building will tell the world how singapore has grown rapidly each year.
jacksonteo78
2006-07-22 07:53:57 UTC
While we actively create our future through planning, a distinctive global city is also about capturing memory and retaining identity in our physical environment.



These buildings are the works of our pioneering batches of local architects, capturing the spirit of our young nation. They stand out today as important landmarks to many Singaporeans.
?
2014-09-25 19:55:29 UTC
Life in a super-max, no parole. I'm talking about hard core drugs not marijuana. That applies to everyone from the street corner thug on up the food chain. But not to the addict who might run a bag or two for his own.Now, if they want to give up the guy who lives in the Hamptons and drives a Bentley, we can give them a slap on the wrist and lifetime protection. Drug abuse has taken a terrible toll on humankind We all know someone who has been affected in some way by this horrendous mania.
sadia1905
2006-07-23 02:21:26 UTC
historical buildings and moniments in Singapore are an important part of our (singaporeans') history and culture, they are also national icons which give us a sense of national pride and thus help to forge national identy and social cohesion i Singapore. it gives us a sense of common origin and togatherness which makes us proud to be singaporeans! =)

other factors contributing to our national identity are national heroes, national flag, anthem and pledge, and our ratial conposition.
NT
2006-07-21 07:00:12 UTC
Our history must not be as rich as the other countries but we all have to start somewhere.. these historical buildings & monuments look to be the best thing to start off with.
countess_amalina
2006-07-21 05:20:34 UTC
Hmm... does Singapore has much historical building left??? Well, some of them does remind us of what had happened to us, what our forefathers had done & so on... With this, why do they want to tear down the current National Stadium???
Blessed
2006-07-21 02:43:41 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments present physical evidences of events that unfolded over time during the past. They also serve to re-kindle national consciousness of past events.
wlee76
2006-07-21 01:42:46 UTC
They show-cast the path Singapore have gone throught. They let people know where singapore came from, how singapore progress and where singapore is heading to.



Without them, Singapore will tends to lose its charm, and roots. they are a part of what/who singapore are. Without our own unique identity Singapore cannot stand-out from the crowd
*-* *
2006-07-23 04:11:31 UTC
It would be how much we have move on from our past, be it good or bad the memories, these historical buildings and monuments shouldn't hold us back just because of that. the people of today shouldn't be faulted if the memories are not remembered and also the people of today shouldn't keep on harping about the good ones as well.
deathgodhorus
2006-07-20 20:47:24 UTC
As a mutli racial country, the historical building and monuments of the different races helps to enhance our identity as a nation that can live in racial harmony.
2006-07-20 23:27:37 UTC
They are remnants of our roots and past, the very mentioning of them enables people to recognise us immediately. For example, when someone say "Merlion", the country Singapore comes into our mind instantaneously.

Therefore, a National Identity is important not only for us to be known by the world, but also for ourselves to gain knowledge of our past.
etbk8
2006-07-20 22:18:19 UTC
By having a story to tell of the different people who lives and works there, of the Father who work hard to provide food on the table, the Mother tolling all day to provide a comfortable home to her loved one and of the Children playing and studying hard so as one day he or she can be a good Citizen to the Country.
Bick
2006-07-22 09:06:29 UTC
Historical building mark the importance of our heritage and our past. These building must be kept to educate and remind our younger / future generations of our root and to institute a sense of belonging. Without knowledge of the past, we will not know our future.
inky_paradise
2006-07-21 10:52:01 UTC
Singapore has not much history.. and we are making our won history each and every day.. historical building and mounments are remind the fast pace singaporean to remember who they are and know their own root and culture..
ITCHY
2006-07-21 19:58:58 UTC
The buildings shows our roots , it is our link to another era of time where people of all walks ,all religion, all over the globe come to this place in time and space to survived as a community. That is our identity!
Community's Well
2006-07-21 08:22:44 UTC
MERLION one and only in the world to be identified as Singapore's own.



The LION being the original anme of this island as a LION CITY and the nature of a MERLION adds to the fact that we are a gracious nation.
bluroblur
2006-07-21 06:10:41 UTC
It symbolizes the fruit of our forefathers' labour and reflects their most sincere move to upbringing the future Singapore.



Without their efforts, Singapore would not advance into the 21st century in becoming the most recognized/modern city.
lucas l
2006-07-21 10:44:33 UTC
Just like the trophy a sportsman raise with pride that reminds him of his struggles, perseverance and his final triumph or a medal of honour awarded to a war veteran for his valour that will always remind him of those who had fallen before him.



National heritage will inspire familarity and awe when a grandfather tell his grandson of his passing associated with the structures or a father to his son of the adventures he had visiting them before he 's a man.



All in all,we preserve,so that it may be marvelled by the future, lest they forget the people who built them, used them or simply the people who are marvelled by their future in this land.
anwarrahman
2006-07-21 06:43:59 UTC
The design was unique here with different etnic groups and also take into account of the origin of our forefathers who decide to stay here in Singapore that makes it so unique that blends easily with other cultures.
ffast71
2006-07-21 07:09:55 UTC
Memories
Puck Wah G
2006-07-20 18:17:21 UTC
it shows us that different culture/races could live happily together. This build us to become One People, One Nation and One Singapore.
2006-07-21 07:39:13 UTC
They remind us of the sacrifices, achievements and actions taken by our forefathers into ensuring us the future, this future, that they themselves had hoped for living. Recognising these monuments, we recognise they're dreams. And in that, we will always stay humble to who and where we were, are and will be. Singaporeans.
00christine00
2006-07-22 04:31:01 UTC
It represents how we come about to be Singaporean! It also represents our culture and our way of living. Some buildings and monuments have some distinct architecture of our multi-racial society which is prove to our racial harmony society.
Raj K
2006-07-20 18:51:42 UTC
Historical buildings and monuments are like story books Who built it? why? how?....search a bit, find out the answers and you'll probably find out who we are, why we are what we are and how it all came about too!
?
2016-03-16 06:20:03 UTC
Taj Mahal
rockniker
2006-07-21 02:50:19 UTC
those buildings and stuff r there so sch hav sth to teach abt in their social studies to kids. dont think these days ppl care abt sg or national identity. only care abt how to earn $$. many also migrate to other countries. old buildings r jus for show, but really hav no use.
Jiamin
2006-07-22 23:09:26 UTC
It reminds us of the things that our fore fathers did... their contribution, what they went through. It also shows the tourist how singapore was like when it was back then.
ksl
2006-07-20 20:28:06 UTC
It actually tells people from other countries whats our roots and lifestyle and stories from our ancestors what / how a s'porea shld be like. its just like when you talk of germany you think of their museum and historical building
2006-07-21 04:18:06 UTC
It reminds us about the leaders of Singapore.
efyusikay
2006-07-22 07:29:19 UTC
It symbolizes our unique multicultural society living and working together as one to develop our independant nation for our future generation.
rush
2006-07-23 05:43:06 UTC
Besides knowing which race & religion of people were the forefathers of the particular place. It also helps to know the state of mind of the one who had build it and the state of intellect of the present community who fight to preserve it.
Girl
2006-07-20 18:51:46 UTC
They represent the people that were here first, gone now and what they left behind. A legacy, that's us.. A multiracial, multicultural society.
nur z
2006-07-22 23:44:06 UTC
it is to remind us of our roots.our ancestors and how hard they had worked to make Singapore the way it is today.our colourful and unique past that makes us Singaporeans.
ms_adelene
2006-07-23 06:39:09 UTC
these places that are preserved are those related to our ethinicity, culture, religion & race. these places are of high importance that shape the country to what it is today. many of these buildings are converted into places of interest. it provides information to our young as well as to tourist who are interested to know our past. preservation helps us remember the past and enable us to look into the future.
cheng c
2006-07-23 08:12:26 UTC
they were built by our fore fathers who came from all different countries and different ethenic groups.the designs of these house were similiar to those back in their countries so having them here is like having a building similiar to the ones in china,india etc. so its like visiting little ancient china, india etc when we see such buildings!
civic9353
2006-07-20 18:25:46 UTC
these monuments symoblised our multi-cultural society hence contributing to a multi racial Singapore.
2006-07-22 10:23:51 UTC
it help us remember how and where we came from and gives us a unique identity that makes every one of us different and much more interesting people.
anonymous_0110
2006-07-21 05:01:54 UTC
They help us remember our roots and origins, tell us who we really are and also what lies beneath the Sg history, and the facts of it.
bonnienyce
2006-07-21 01:00:52 UTC
By letting other tourist a place to go to besides shopping.



SHYEAH!

To not forget our forefathers, i guess.
Syaz Lynn
2006-07-20 20:43:08 UTC
it reminds us of our ancestors..the way they live and the way they die..but so sad many of these monuments and historical buildings are going down..the stadium i tink..it reli brings many wonderful memories to me wen i was young...so sad,reli so sad..
2006-07-21 17:17:10 UTC
It reminds us of what our forefathers had to go through, and the pains that they've taken to get us to where we are today.
2006-07-22 04:43:45 UTC
Just for sentimental value
kzzxguy
2006-07-21 12:36:42 UTC
it increase the price of land on the surround area
tan g
2006-07-23 01:13:20 UTC
to knw n understand our past history n how spore has come tis far.even we r small n young but we are proud of our history.

happy birthday spore!!!
domestic shopaholic
2006-07-20 07:42:50 UTC
They remind us of our roots, where we came from, how we evolved in our newfound home, and how we'd like our lives to me like.
Mel t
2006-07-20 19:13:56 UTC
its a library of history collected!
tayevonne
2006-07-23 21:17:23 UTC
it helps us to understand the history of our country and also the reasons why our forefathers came here. it also helps the young to appreciate what they have.
nurr j
2006-07-20 18:16:54 UTC
they remaind us where we born and where we come from our born in inthe world stomuch
fbobcreations
2006-07-21 00:58:01 UTC
You won't know where you're heading until you know where you've been
2006-07-21 08:37:13 UTC
As a history student, I would reply with an emphatic YES! that historical buildings and monuments in Singapore contribute greatly to our national identity. I would explain exactly how these pieces of brick and mortar carve the Singaporean identity to the skeptics out there.



Singapore, albeit a young nation of nearly 41 years, actually possesses a rich heritage of about 200 years! One might argue that that's virtually impossible, but the answer lay in that our forefathers were immigrants. For the sake of this discussion, I would choose to focus on the Telok Ayer region, which has been conserved into a Heritage zone by the Urban Redevelopment Authority of Singapore.



The conservation of the Telok Ayer region is by no means coincidental. That area actually marked the beginning of a new life for our forefathers when they landed there after a long sea voyage from their faraway homelands. The many historical buidings and monuments are testaments to the trials and tribulations endured by our ancestors in Singapore. Singapore is a country made up of people from vastly different communities. The relics of the past that still stands today shed some light on who were our early founding fathers. I would now give a brief synopsis of some of the historical buidings and monuments that play a pivotal role in Singapore's heritage.



Telok Ayer Street

Tracing a line from Boat Quay, down along the southern end of Chinatown, Telok Ayer Street runs along the original waterfront of Singapore’s coast. Land reclamation in 1887 swallowed up the bay, but some of Singapore’s oldest temples and buildings still survive as a legacy of the area’s waterfront location in the city’s early years.



1: Yueh Hai Ching Temple

Singapore’s oldest Taoist temple, Yueh Hai Ching was built in 1826 for sailors and immigrants to give thanks to the Gods for their safe passage from China. It was, and still is, a meeting place for the Teowchew community.



2: Pekin Street

Today, this area is filled with restaurants, bars and offices. It was however, in Singapore’s early years, the centre for the coolie trade and its agents. The buildings have been refurbished now, reminding the area of its past.





3: Fuk Tak Chi Temple

Built by Chinese immigrants to Singapore as thanksgiving for a safe voyage to their new home, the Fuk Tak Chi temple has now been turned into a small museum showing the area’s history.



4: Ying Fo Fui Kun Clan Association

When Chinese immigrants arrived in Singapore, many joined clan associations that represented the area they were from in China. This is one of those that survives today, representing the Hakka community.





5: Nagore Durgha Shrine

Built in 1828, this Islamic Shrine was built by the Chulia settlers from southern India. The most interesting thing about this building is the creative mix of western and eastern architecture.





6: Telok Ayer Green

Commemorating the Malay, Indian and Chinese communities that settled in this area, Telok Ayer Green is a quaint little park filled with sculptures of the street’s former inhabitants as well as various signboards detailing its history.



7: Thian Hock Keng Temple

Built in 1821, this is the oldest Hokkien temple in Singapore. Dedicated to the Goddess of the Sea, Ma Cho Po, this was the first stop for many new immigrants to Singapore.



8: Al Abrar Mosque

Originally built in 1827 as a thatched hut, the Al Abrar Mosque has grown into a building spanning the width of three shophouses. Like the Nagore Durgha Shrine, this was also built by the Chulia settlers of southern India.



Fuk Tak Chi Museum

Built by Chinese immigrants to Singapore as thanksgiving for a safe voyage to their new home, the Fuk Tak Chi Museum on Telok Ayer Street is a fascinating place to learn about the immigrant past of Singapore. In the days when Chinese immigrants settled here, Telok Ayer Street ran along the shoreline of a bay that has long since been reclaimed from the sea. The area was where many Hakka and Cantonese immigrants settled as it was also the area where a lot of coolie agents had their offices. The Museum was originally a temple, built over the years from 1824 onwards, and dedicated to the God Tua Pek Kong, also known as Dai Bak Kong. Inside today you’ll see an interesting array of exhibits telling of the lives of the people who settled here, while outside onteh streets around Far East Square and Pekin Street you can still see the shophouses that where lived in by the very same immigrants. Today the shophouses are home to restaurants, bars and offices, but they still maintain a charm of yesteryear.



Sri Mariamman Temple

The oldest Hindu Temple in Singapore, the Sri Mariamman temple was originally built in 1827 by one of the city’s first Indian businessmen. Although the temple you see today is vastly different from the first one built – the first one was made of wood – it still remains in the same place and attracts thousands of visitors every year. The temple is dedicated to the goddess Mariamman who has the power to cure smallpox and cholera and today is a favourite place for Hindu couples to have their wedding. While it is also one of Singapore’s top tourist attractions, it is important to remember it is also a place of worship and treated accordingly.



After I had identified the historical buildings and monuments that our government feels are important to our national heritage, I would explain further how they are used to contribute to our national identity.



Knowledge is useless if it's not imparted to the next generation. The Education Ministry incorporates Social Studies from the Primary Level to inculcate in the pupils from a very early age a sense of belonging to the community and country; and cultivating the right instincts for reinforcing social cohesion. Schools are encouraged to bring pupils to sites of historical value and engaging in Social Studies Field Work. Rosyth School is a solid example of a school that imbues her pupils with National Education messages by taking upper primary pupils to places like Chinatown which incorporates Telok Ayer Street.



To conclude, I would like to reiterate that historical sites in Singapore contribute to our national identity greatly by allowing future generations to study about the lives of our ancestors and founding fathers. Our national identiy could thus be forged through the combined understanding of the 'gifts' that our forefathers built for us.
louissoon
2006-07-21 01:41:31 UTC
they contribute very well
siva
2006-07-23 06:33:51 UTC
its a symbol of our past life how the past was like its like when we see them its remind us of wat our grandparents suffer then we should keep it


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...