Question:
Why did the Nazi's hate the Jews?
Nianque
2007-03-28 16:32:53 UTC
I understand that anti-semitism is still a serious issue. But I've never understood it and no one has ever been able to explain it to me.

The only thing I've ever heard is, "Because the Jews killed Jesus." But if Jesus hadn't been killed wouldn't we all be going to Hell? His primary purpose on Earth was to be sacrificed on the cross. Does it really matter who actually held the hammer 2000 years ago? And if that's the reason, why didn't they try to wipe out the Itallians (Romans)?

Rascism doesn't make any sense to me but I at least understand the reasonings behind most of the other racial tensions but that one completely eludes me.
Seventeen answers:
zurioluchi
2007-03-28 16:56:55 UTC
Good complex question, there is no easy or all encompassing answer to that..



Root of Hitler's/Nazi Hatred for Jews



There are many contributing factors and possible theories. Here are some points to consider:



* The only reason the jews were killed by the nazis were that the nazis were jealous that the jews had the riches and the main businesses, and a great life thats it 11 million people died of jealousy



* Jealousy. Some Jews were successful and held powerful positions in Austria and Germany in the 1920s and 1930s. At the same time, the world was suffering in the Great Depression. For various reasons, including war reparations for World War I, Germany was being hit the hardest by the worldwide economic depression. Successful Jews were envied and blamed for "taking German jobs."



* During World War I, communism was on the rise. Lenin's Revolution had forced Russia out of the war. The German Army at times faced near rebellion among their own troops. This contributed to Germany being forced to sue for peace. Since some socialist/communist leaders were Jewish this was exploited as another reason for Germans to hate Jews. Hitler often spoke of Bolshevik (communist) Jewry. There is still a strong association in some people's minds between Jews and leftism of various kinds.



* Hitler and other Germans absorbed some of their parents' racism. Anti-Semitism has a long history.



* Some Germans held to the belief that "Jewish bankers" were responsible for the Treaty of Versailles because they stopped funding WWI.



* The Balfour Declaration of 1917 supposedly proves that Jews betrayed Germany in World War I. According to one who holds this theory, "During the Great War (World War I), members of the Zionist Jewish elite bartered with England and promised to bring the United States into the war in exchange for Palestine. This is the root cause of the belief that the Jews contributed to the defeat and subsequent economic rape of Germany in the post-war years." However, this wasn't something mentioned much in Germany and seems to be a post-1945 (!) preoccupation of a few anti-Zionists.



Check the link for more



Have a pleasant day.
Kik
2007-03-28 18:56:52 UTC
I've read some of the answers and whilst most of them have good points the real reason that Hitler hated the Jews was because the German people needed to hate somebody. After WW1 Germany was in ruins and it wasn't changing fast. People were starving and dying due to the harsh reparations payments and the huge inflation that resulted in astronomical prices that nobody could afford.



Hitler came to power and told the German people that it wasn't their fault that Germany was in the position it was in - it was the fault of the Jews and the black people and the homosexuals. Anybody who was different was targeted as being the reason for Germany's ruin. The Jew had it worst of all because Germany, esp. in the South is a Catholic country and it is a long tradition of anti-semitism.



It has been suggested that Hitler's hatred of them may have come from him being partly Jewish whether or not that is true is debatable as are all historical facts but it is possible.



I agree whole heartedly with you about not understanding it. Jews are hated for their riches and their involvement in banking and other 'rich' trades but no-one asks why these are the trades they are involved in - the reason being that if you are persecuted against it is far easier to carry money or gold/jewels than it is to run with carpentry tools or a kiln.
Dane
2007-03-28 16:51:48 UTC
The nazi's simply industrialized the "pogrom". Pogroms had been going on for centuries, since the end of the roman era in the west. Jews were not the only group targeted,but the group most often targeted.

Jews have always been despised primarily because of the "chosen people" label, their insularity,their militant behavior, the difficulty in governing them and with their cutural emphasis on success measured by movable wealth.



They were often viewed as acquiring and controlling the wealth of nations.

From much of the propiganda floating around the western and eastern worlds today that perception apparently hasn't changed very much.



Incidentally, the more pragmatic reason for the nazi's persecution of the jews was that they typically represented the intelligensia and the prosperious middle class. These two classes represented a threat to the Nazis because they were not easily swayed and controlled by the Nazis message, It also meant that the Nazis could confiscate all their wealth, including their gold teeth, which were melted down and sold to the swiss.
starjammer
2007-03-28 16:42:20 UTC
I suppose its the primary reason of anti-semitic sentiments: their impalement of Jesus Christ 2000 years ago.The Romans (citizens of the Roman Empire) were already long gone during this period.Also,the Nazis need some scapegoats because of the consequence of the Versailles Treaty after World War I.They also just ride with the current prejudice of the time to be the most popular party in Germany.
2007-03-31 15:36:07 UTC
"Because the Jews killed Jesus" is something I've heard a lot too, and I think it's the stupidest theory I've ever heard. I think It's just racism, and what causes racism I believe is fear. They were probably secretly afraid the Jews were more intelligent as a race, and couldn't stand the competition. I got your message in my question about Bush, and this country's schools are still falling way behind the rest of the world in math and science.
?
2014-11-07 21:24:06 UTC
"To answer this, you have to understand the history of the Jewish people + their strong family ties & tenacity. For a thousand years, the Jewish people were alternately expelled from many different countries of the world for, what very well seems like, "jealously" by non Jews- jealously & fear of the Jew's success and wealth- while gentiles(non Jews) suffered around them. Jews understood & knew how to be prosperous(strong family + community ties are said to be part of this success), while gentiles generally believed that if they were to save themselves, the Jews had to go. Hitler simply took this to the next level in 1930's Germany.
2007-03-31 11:54:59 UTC
Reasons:

1.Jews KilledJesus. ( dont realize they were told by god, judas was told by jesus, jesus died for your sins)

2. Hitler hated them because he didnt get along with his father who hit him a lot.

---->Hitler's father was the illegitimate child of a cook named (Maria Anna) Schickelgruber. This cook, the grandmother of Adolf Hitler, was working for a Jewish family named Frankenburger, when she became pregnant. Frankenburger paid Schickelbruber, a paternity allowance from the time of the child's birth up to his fourteenth year.

From a secret report by the Nazi Hans Frank. Written in 1930

3. Jews were doing well in society economy. they were helping the country just as much as the so called "aryans" were. they wanted peace. they loved GermanY!!!!!!!!!

4. people didnt realize jews were the ones that allowed christianity. if it wasnt for them there wouldnt be no jesus. there would be no you ( to anyone thats racist or if you are chritian.)



to any neo-nazi- Darn you son of a Nazi
billy_bong_horton
2007-03-28 16:45:44 UTC
hitler didnt hate the jews because they killed jesus. he hated jews because they were wealthy and acted better than him.



at the time the jewish community was in the upper class and hitler hated anyone who was better than him so he attacked all jews.



hitlers reasons had nothing to do with the death of christ.
2007-03-28 16:36:34 UTC
They hated the Jews because their leaders told them to.
2007-03-29 21:03:08 UTC
Looks like answer number 11, KiK, nailed the answer.



I will just have to agree with her.
armando j
2007-03-29 03:53:17 UTC
first, no one needed to hate anyone.



Hitler was born in austria, and when austria and germany became economically challenged, he stated to his followers that the jews were the cause of this disaster.
nycmachinegun
2007-03-28 16:41:13 UTC
when they lost world war 1 all the german-jews (jews living in german) were happy so they said jews brought them failure
Riccardo
2007-03-28 16:43:32 UTC
the nazis picked on the jews because they think that they undermine their german traditional way of life
almondebaby
2007-03-28 16:39:06 UTC
I THINK THERE IS MANY REASONS BUT I THINK THAT ALL OF THEM ARE BAD REASONS.WELL ONE REASON IS BEING AFRAID OF GETTING KILLED OR EVEN GETTING ARRESTED THEY WHERE JUST SCARED.BUT I THINK THERE BY STANDING MADE THE HATRET OK AND I KNOW ITS WRONG.
sec_cogley
2007-03-28 16:54:11 UTC
the nazis had no choice whether or not they liked the jews or not b/c hitler had them all convinced that jews were bad and that he was a good person. hitler was said to have some jewish in his blood and look wat he did to them. so instead of saying heil hitler i say f-u-c-k hitler.
2007-03-28 16:37:59 UTC
because of their hair.....ok i guessed that but its because of their religon i beleive
2007-03-29 16:09:05 UTC
“Although the Crusades were directed against the Muslims in the East,” says The Encyclopedia of Religion, “the zeal of the Crusaders was exercised on the Jews who lived in the lands from which the Crusaders were recruited, that is, in Europe. A popular motif among the Crusaders was vengeance for the

death of Jesus, and the Jews became the first victims. Persecution of the Jews occurred in Rouen in 1096, followed quickly by massacres in Worms, Mainz, and Cologne.” This was but a forerunner of the anti-Semitic spirit of the Holocaust days of Nazi Germany.



Throughout the Middle Ages, the Roman Catholic Church presented itself as the true religion. However, the Jewish people had never relinquished their claim to being the chosen people of God. The inability of the church to convince the Jews of the need to convert led to frustration and frequently to violence and persecution. During the Crusades tens of thousands of Jews were massacred or burned at the stake when given the choice between baptism or death. In many lands church-inspired anti-Semitism was the order of the day.

A different spirit, though, prevailed in Catholic Spain of the 12th and 13th centuries. Jews were allowed religious liberty—as long as they did not attack the Christian faith—and were even given important positions within the king’s court. But after about a century of such favor, Dominican priests took steps to lessen the Jewish influence in society and to convert the Jews to Catholicism. -- " "Nahmanides--Did He Refute Christianity", in 4/15/1997 Watchtower



While intolerance is invariably associated with feelings of superiority, these, more likely than not, are only superficial; underneath lies a feeling of insecurity, of inferiority; in fact, a fear because of weakness. Thus the campaign of anti-Semitism of the Nazis was so successful for the reason that so many German “Aryans” feared the Jews because of their achievements in the fields of finance, science and the arts. The same may even be said of the current world-wide racial intolerance; it is coupled with fear of harm. Not, in this instance, because of achievements but because of the numerical superiority of these other races." -- "Intolerance Is A Sign of Weakness", in 6/01/59 Watchtower magazine



# Hitler hated ANYONE whom he PERCEIVED as a threat ...

in any Way, Shape, or Form!



"History reveals that at the outset of Hitler’s persecution of German Jews, Cardinal Faulhaber of Munich preached sermons in which he defended the Jews. Other heroic clerics condemned outright the Nazi laws which forbade intermarriage between “Aryans” and Jews. After the outbreak of World War II in Europe, Hitler closed Catholic schools, suppressed the Catholic press, and, in Poland, closed all convents, monasteries, and seminaries ..."



From what I understand, Hitler actually made a deal with the Catholic church --(He was baptized in said church During WW2)-- that it would become the state religion when Germany 'won the war' ...



The Enciclopedia del Novecento, edited by the Institute of the Italian Encyclopedia, discusses tensions between Hitler’s Nazi regime and the Roman Catholic Church under the heading “National Socialism.” This authority states: “But since the episcopacy, after agreeing to an unusually obliging concordat [with the Nazis], was hesitant to go openly against the regime, and since Secretary of State cardinal Pacelli (later pope Pius XII) looked favorably on the anti-Bolshevik aspect of the Third Reich . . . the tension never exploded into a formal rupture. . . . Nevertheless relations between the regime and the churches, who avoided absolutely uttering a word against the persecution of Jews and Jehovah’s Witnesses, were in a state of suspension, since Hitler, against Bormann’s view, forbade actions clearly anticlerical until the war would be over. . . . The majority of the clergy of the two creeds, [Lutheran and Catholic] maintained behavior that was outwardly loyal to the regime . . . In foreign politics the conciliatory attitude of the Vatican was of valid support to the regime, especially during the stage of its rise to power.”--Volume IV, page 519.



DURING the pope’s visit to Germany last May, he referred to “the hardships the Church faced in the Nazi era.” The Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger reported this, then added: “He failed to mention that some leading Catholic clergymen were lacking in courage, preaching sermons in support of denominational schools, but not against persecution of the Jews.” (1987 news)



"Catholic Church Seeks Forgiveness" -- (4/22/98 wtw news)

The Roman Catholic Church in France has issued a formal “Declaration of Repentance,” asking God and the Jewish people for forgiveness for the “indifference” the Catholic Church showed toward the persecution of Jews under France’s wartime Vichy government. From 1940 to 1944, more than 75,000 Jews were arrested and deported from France to Nazi death camps. In a statement read by Archbishop Olivier de Berranger, the church admitted that it had allowed its own interests “to obscure the biblical imperative of respect for every human being created in the image of God,” reports the French newspaper Le Monde. Although a handful of French clergy spoke out in favor of the Jews, the majority supported the Vichy government and its policies. The declaration stated in part: “The church must recognize that in regard to the persecution of the Jews, and especially in regard to manifold anti-Semitic measures decreed by the Vichy authorities, indifference by far prevailed over indignation. Silence was the rule, and words in favor of the victims the exception. . . . Today, we confess that this silence was a mistake. We also recognize that the church in France failed in its mission as the educator of people’s consciences.”



"Scriptures show that there is such a thing as community responsibility. Thus in ancient Israel the older men of a city had to take certain action to absolve their city from bloodguilt in the case of an unsolved murder, for the entire city was held responsible. (Deut. 21:1-9) For the same reason the entire tribe of Benjamin was adjudged guilty for refusing to surrender the good-for-nothing men of Gibeah who had abused to the death a certain Levite’s concubine. (Judg. 20:8-48) In fact, such responsibility is recognized even in modern times; an example being the way West Germany, --though now democratic-- has voluntarily chosen to indemnify the Jews and other victims of Nazi persecution."



Simultaneous with bitter persecution of Jews in Nazi Germany, hostility against Jehovah’s witnesses flared up.



In his book entitled “The Nazi State,” Professor Ebenstein of Princeton University wrote concerning Jehovah’s witnesses: “When the witnesses did not give up the struggle for their religious convictions, a campaign of terror was launched against them which surpassed anything perpetrated against other victims of Nazism in Germany. . . . The sufferings of Jehovah’s Witnesses in the camps were even worse than those meted out to Jews, pacifists or Communists. Small as the sect is, each member seems to be a fortress which can be destroyed but never taken.” Also regarding persecution of Jehovah’s witnesses, Richard Mathison states in his book God Is a Millionaire: “All this persecution has worn well. . . . And, perhaps, the sternly conventional have a lesson to learn from the unyielding courage of this persecuted minority. During the Korean War, the products of easy Protestantism, of our military schools and our better colleges cracked by the score under the stress and blandishments of Communist brainwashing. A Pentagon study of the problem brought forth a red-faced conclusion: Those few Jehovah’s Witnesses who ended up as prisoners of war . . . withstood to a man the scientific, psychological efforts to convert them to Communism--better than a number of patriotic West Pointers.”



In 1933, there were about 25,000 of Jehovah’s Witnesses in Germany. Thousands of them were among the first people to be thrown into Nazi camps and prisons. They declared their neutrality as Christians toward all kinds of political and military activity. They did not heil Hitler. They refused to accept the Nazi racist ideology and to share in Hitler’s war machine. About 2,000 died, more than 250 of them by execution.

Furthermore, Witness prisoners helped fellow prisoners to endure --including Jews and others-- by instilling Bible-based hope in them and by sharing whatever they had with sick and weak ones, often offering some of their last piece of bread. During the early years of Nazi persecution, they also smuggled out information about the existence of concentration camps and about what was going on in them. Since then, in their globally circulated magazines, The Watchtower and Awake!, they have published numerous articles dealing with Nazi atrocities as well as survivors’ life stories.



A church magazine in Germany charged that the Witnesses and the Jews were coconspirators in revolutionary movements. In response, the April 15, 1930, German edition of The Golden Age (forerunner of Awake!) stated: "We have no reason to regard this false accusation as an insult—as we are convinced that the Jew is at least as valuable a person as a nominal Christian; but we reject the above untruth of the church tabloid because it is aimed at deprecating our work, as if it were being done not for the sake of the Gospel but for the Jews."



Thus, professor of history John Weiss wrote: "The Witnesses were free of German racial nationalism and had not brooded for centuries over the failure of the Jews to convert.



# Jews were persecuted for their race, whereas JWs were persecuted for their chosen course in life. JWs were the only ones persecuted who could have signed themselves out of their 'persecuted circumstances'.

It was claimed that the Jews & JWs were collaborating against the government, but that was never the case.

It was claimed that JWs had a particular interest in the Jews, but that was not the case, either.



In our own time, anti-Semitism in Christendom culminated in the Nazi Holocaust. Though many factors were involved, religious hatred cannot be ignored as one of the main ones. And if some in Christendom would deny this, the fact that “Christians,” both Catholics and Protestants, were among the ones that did the killing or condoned it is undeniable. Elie Wiesel sums up the Jewish view in his book A Jew Today: “How is one to explain that neither Hitler nor Himmler was ever excommunicated by the church? That Pius XII never thought it necessary, not to say indispensable, to condemn Auschwitz and Treblinka? That among the S.S. a large proportion were believers who remained faithful to their Christian ties to the end? That there were killers who went to confession between massacres? And that they all came from Christian families and had received a Christian education?” Therefore, just how much faith could Jewish people be expected to demonstrate in someone whose name was for centuries connected with every humiliation and blow that they received?



Between 1980 and 1996, John Paul II ‘recognized the Church’s historic faults or asked forgiveness’ at least 94 times, says Vatican commentator Luigi Accattoli in his book Quando il papa chiede perdono (When the Pope Asks Forgiveness). According to Accattoli, “in the Catholic Church, only the pope can rightly make a mea culpa.” And this he has done, referring to the most controversial pages of Catholic history---the Crusades, wars, support of dictatorships, division in the churches, anti-Semitism, the Inquisitions, the Mafia, and racism. In a memorandum sent in 1994 to the cardinals (which is considered by some to be the most important document of the pontificate), John Paul II proposed “a general and millennial confession of sins.”



Several prelates have followed the pope’s example. In December 1994 the Italian newspaper Il Giornale reported: “Many American bishops appeared on television and publicly asked forgiveness.” For what? For underestimating the problem of pedophile priests, to the detriment of many young victims. In January 1995 the newspaper La Repubblica reported on “a gesture unprecedented in the history of contemporary Catholicism”—the problem of Pope Pius XII’s silence in connection with the Holocaust was addressed. In January 1995 the same newspaper reported that the German episcopate asked forgiveness for the “many faults” of Roman Catholics who supported the crimes of the Nazis.

--"The Churches Confess", in 3/01/98 Watchtower magazine



# The above are a few excerpts of what I found on the subject. Clearly, the Catholic church played a large part in anti-semitism.

Below are links to a few of the online articles that apply to your question:



Christendom Has Betrayed God and the Bible :

... Unbiblical Doctrines + Ungodly Actions = Not Christian http://www.watchtower.org/library/pr/article_04.htm



Whose Century Was It? http://www.watchtower.org/e/20030115/article_01.htm



Who Really Rules the World ... ?

http://www.watchtower.org/library/t22/who_rules.htm



Advanced On-site Search

(For more info, or, when a link becomes modified.) http://www.watchtower.org/search/search_e.htm


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...